Bloomberg News, quickly becoming the leading muckraker of the financial markets, has another blockbuster story today, on the heels of its release of information about Federal Reserve bailouts. Here they have former Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson essentially aiding and abetting an insider trading scheme while in office, as far as I can tell:
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson stepped off the elevator into the Third Avenue offices of hedge fund Eton Park Capital Management LP in Manhattan. It was July 21, 2008, and market fears were mounting [...] amid tumbling home prices and near-record foreclosures, attention was focused on a new source of contagion: Fannie Mae (FNMA) and Freddie Mac, which together had more than $5 trillion in mortgage-backed securities and other debt outstanding, Bloomberg Markets reports in its January issue [...]
On the morning of July 21, before the Eton Park meeting, Paulson had spoken to New York Times reporters and editors, according to his Treasury Department schedule. A Times article the next day said the Federal Reserve and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency were inspecting Fannie and Freddie’s books and cited Paulson as saying he expected their examination would give a signal of confidence to the markets.
At the Eton Park meeting, he sent a different message, according to a fund manager who attended. Over sandwiches and pasta salad, he delivered that information to a group of men capable of profiting from any disclosure.
Paulson told the dozen hedge fund managers in attendance – in a nice detail, Bloomberg mentions that at least five of them previously worked at Goldman Sachs, where Paulson was the longtime CEO – that he wanted to put Fannie and Freddie into conservatorship, which is what ended up happening in September. He even detailed how the common stock would get wiped out. These were 12 of the most likely people to profit from this disclosure, several weeks before it happened, on the advice of the Tresaury Secretary himself.
Bloomberg could not dig up any evidence of acting on trades, though there was all kinds of short action on the GSEs throughout this period. While Bloomberg tries to soft-pedal the crime committed, finding law professors to say that nothing illegal transpired, it’s pretty obvious that what happened was at least unethical, and a clear example of crony capitalism at work. The bigger problems is how hard it is to determine what’s actually legal:
“The bottom line is that senior-level people in Washington, in the name of keeping in touch with their stakeholders, are tipping their hands,” says Adam Zagorin, a senior fellow at the Project on Government Oversight, a Washington watchdog group. “You can’t prosecute them for insider trading if they didn’t trade the shares. You may not be able to even reprimand them. What the hell are the rules?”
Paulson’s spokeswoman referred Bloomberg to Paulson’s book about the financial crisis, which makes no mention of the meeting. And that’s probably where it ends. It takes a journalist outlet to uncover these sordid details, rather than an investigative entity. The flurry of insider trading prosecutions apparently do not extend to a former Treasury Secretary allowing hedge fund cronies to steal from the government.
This is tied into the burgeoning questions around insider trading in Congress, which also doesn’t have a whole lot of restrictions attached. Now that 60 Minutes has told a (somewhat poorly rendered) story about it, Congress has leapt to action to protect its reputation. Even Spencer Bachus, accused of insider trading in the report, scheduled a hearing on the legislation. There’s a more populist sentiment against this kind of behavior in Washington. It remains to be seen whether that will extend to Paulson.




76 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
The severity of shock at learning that Hank would do such a thing is simply indescribable.
The severity of shock at learning that Hank is now a senior fellow at the University of Chicago
is simply indescribable.
Hahahahahahaha, And a hearty Good Morning to you, too!
This is insider trading right that means arrests sorry its suppose to mean arrests.
The severity of shock that would result if President “Let’s Look Forward and Not Backward” would prosecute this high-octane criminal would be simply indescribable.
The Chicago School of Economics probably considers him a God of Unregulated Markets, Insider Trading, Crony Capitalism and most of all he stuck the tax payers with a bill to save the 1%. Which of course led to cuts in SS, Medicare and now calls for less taxes on the rich.
Paulson set up a Shock Doctrine which is likely to achieve every dream Milt also of UIC dreamed of. Ayn Rand would be proud too!
I think Paulson deserves his evil Cred and UIC is a fitting place for him prison is a more fitting place.
The shock would be Obama’s poll numbers going above 60% and all the Media talking heads who claim America wants more compromise from Obama being proven wrong. Paulson stole from us we want our cash back!
Even Spencer Bachus, accused of insider trading in the report, scheduled a hearing on the legislation.
Since when do we let the actually accused investigate themselves?
When and where is the tipping point that causes something to be done about such open corruption?
Story after story, day after day more bullshit surfaces and nothing.
And not only bullshit, but blatant in your face bs. You know, the “Yeah we did it, it’s illegal and we don’t care” kind of bullshit.
here is an interesting take on bloomberg story
http://thedailybell.com/3298/The-Real-Reason-Bloomberg-Sued-to-Open-Up-Fed-Records
also a week after meeting with the hedge funds paulson lied under oath and told congress there were no problems with fannie and freddie. So he can be prosecuted, but of course he will not.
Finaly as zero hege pointed out some at the meeting work for Plunge Protection Team, whose activities are so secret its meetings are not recorded. I think we all know why?
Therein lies the problem? Who is going to do something about it? they are all in it, and even if they appointed a committee to investigate it too would be compromised and be just more smoke and mirrors
I mean yes I expect a whitewash investigation that at best gives us one scapegoat but come on the powers that be should at least try and make the investigation if there is one look fair.
If your going to tell a lie make it a good one its an insult to expect anyone to fall for something as obvious as this.
I have said many times Bush was a bad liar, I have said Obama is not a Chicago Pol because Obvious Liars in Chicago go to Prison Guys like Mayor Daley and his Dad despite being investigated by the Feds numerous times never go to prison.
We now live in a world where even evil is not a Meritocracy the best liars the most ruthless people if we believe the book “King of the Mountain ” should rule but they don’t.
Instead we get Emperor Nero twice fiddling while our economy burns.
It is cheaper than using outside investigators and the result will be the same
Good point we have him lying to Congress he should go to jail right now if the system were fair.
Sigh it is cheaper but I miss the days when politicians actually feared the American public enough to tell good lies or if they got caught they would resign, go to jail, or die.
Reagan’s CIA chief died just as Iran Contra was getting interesting. Nixon’s VP resigned over bribes, Mayor Daley always had a fall guy ready to fall on his sword. In Chicago the pols were more likely to go to jail than the Mob.
get your priorities straight.
did he lie about a sexual encounter?
did he lie about using steroids?
no, and no.
therefore, not a problem.
these 1% and thier bought goverment are really not leaving any options for us. No charges – no recourse.
If there are no options to make the 1% stop, then what will? Even if the crime is upfront, the DOJ will not do anything.
How can the common man make these people “pay”? Do we use “mob rules” to deal with them? Is it time for “open season on them and their sheltered families? There are crimes for sure, evil crimes and everyone will pay for them. Life and death for us but not them?
The Wall Street criminals have earned a place at the gallows.
DOJ, Eric Holder, 1%er in good standing.
OT
http://dailykos.com/
Kos wrote this good for him if he means it.
Coulda knocked me over with a feather. /s
It is nice to see that the historical record is being made. It would be nicer if this report spurred some action, but why get excited?
TCU, let’s not jump to conclusions. Perhaps those gentlemen, being ethical and honest, each and every one, did not ACT on such information……..
..
..
Sorry, I can’;t say that with a straight face.
Madame Defarge is never around when you need her.
I have some old railroad ties, tar and some feathers. Shall we meet at the Whatburger?????
I think its time we admit we are just one famine, plague, another 10 unemployment points away from a revolution and given global warming causing drought in Texas, immigrants not picking crops in red states resulting in billions of crop losses, the fact we still don’t have National Healthcare and more of the same economic policies I think its only a matter of time before we have a revolution.
Heh. Define “better.” Better neoliberals? When the Democratic Party embraced neoliberal ideology the DP of FDR’s day was buried in the back yard while at the front door they maintain the illusion of being the Party of the people.
I’m beginning to think that some of Obama’a appointments may not have OUR best interest in mind. Eric and Timmy SEEM to be working for the “other side”.
Good point we should look at how much these guys made betting against the economy get some actual numbers then demand all those profits be used to fix our infrastructure and create jobs.
We do need more information NewCarGuy you are right about that and who knows there might be one ethical person in the group.
Bwahahahaha! sorry could not keep straight face.
Note further: If Paulson is prosecuted, then the terrorists win (somehow). Therefore, if he’s not prosecuted, it’s a victory over the forces of terrorism.
oh it would be so nice just to deal with them in that way. But their “bill” is too large for that anymore.
Good thing our side had Barney Frank, Nancy Pelosi and those feisty Congressional Dems fighting for the 99-percenters during this Grand Larceny, eh?
Maybe in the Obama II administration, Treasury Secretary Corzine can clean up this mess.
Good point we must ask what he defines a better liberal as but in the article he is backing a good candidate.
Is it illegal not to report insider trading?
I have a childhood friend who has been telling me for 20 years we would have a revolution. And, he’s “prepared” for one, If ya’ know what I mean. I never believed him before. I didn’t thinkg the PTB would want to “bite the hand that feeds them”. But we are SOOOO getting the short end of the stick, I’m pretty sure that if some things don’t change soon, there’s gonna be trouble. We have been really sold out by this administration.
Maybe the University of Chicago should start a School of Ethic
onomics?Paulson would surely be sitting in the corner of that class with his Dunce hat on.
“Treasury Secty Corzine”……..LOL. That’s a hoot!
..
..
..
You WERE kidding, right???
We have a winner!
I think the revolution has already started in Occupy Wall Street, we’ve just got to continue to offer support and guidance.
The only choice voters have in 2012 is to VOTE AGAINST EVERY incumbent, both Parties, seeking reelection. But how likely is this to happen when FDL, knowing all it does about the corruption and failings of the Obama Administration, will not support such an obviously called for response?
Lets see if Ron Paul is bought off if at the next debate he demands Obama jail Paulson for insider trading then Ron is not bought off granted still a racist and a loon.
But such a move would give him 10 points in polling in the primaries and 20 points in a general election.
Next we need if we can find the information if any GOPers or Obama have any ties to the people at the meeting who traded on this insider trading. Ties like money or they gave members of their firms jobs.
Agree! Silver lining is that it won’t be a big or long revolution, just 535 usa congress members. deal with them and use proper replacements to clean up the banksters and thier partners in the mob
We just need a tipping point I think.
It was MY understanding that “insider trading” was only illegal for non-insiders, like Martha Stewart. I don’t recall any real insiders ever doing time.
There was a poll a couple of months ago showing that the majority wanted to do just that.
UIC is the black tower of evil they reward it Milt’s students went to Chile and helped their economy just as the death squads were being organized. I say destroy the tower.
Agreed!
I agree. I think we are ALREADY at about 44 degrees. 46 and OVER WE GO.
In defense of Paulson, it is easy to see how such a thing could slip out, particularly considering who the luncheon attendees were:
Hank: “Gee, the pasta salad is tangy… Manhattan is lovely in the fall ain’t it?… and didja hear about Fannie and Freddie are stuck with 5T in toxic MBSs…Conservatorship we come!! FYI keep it on the QT.”
Actually I have been telling people here for months vote anything Green, Socialist, Commie anything but Obama/DEM unless you got a real dem in your district to vote for eCHAN’s 45 makes me think I’m a prophet:).
I think we are a pile of leaves doused in gas and waiting for a spark but your scenario is equally possible small difference of opinion.
Nice Snark given his job Paulson knows more about what is insider trading than any of us do considering his old firm heck he probably invented many insider trading schemes. He can not claim accident or he did know the law.
Ahhh Pinochet… hero of the Andes… wasn’t Cain telling us we should adopt the Chilean model for our social safety net? Makes sense, Social Security T-Bills would never need to be reconciled if we just execute 66% of those over age 65.
Be exciting if FDL led the parade. I keep returning for information, but my read is, a lot of steam has come out of the FDL sails in the last year plus. Maybe it’s not possible to walk the fine political line anymore, but personally, I loved the OLD FDL.
Ya know, there’s something about trolls with crystal balls…
back to Chile’s SS success first of all a Lefty is responsible for it.
“After socialist candidate Salvador Allende won the election, he promised to deal with the issue head-on. In fact, at the beginning of 1971, he sent Congress a project for a constitutional amendment that would allow him to nationalize outright all mines, and to transfer all present and future copper fields to the state. Congress passed this amendment on July 11, 1971, by a unanimous vote,[2] and based on it, on July 16, 1971 law 17.450 was promulgated, and became effective immediately. The event was celebrated as the Day of National Dignity (Spanish: Día de la Dignidad Nacional).[3]”
“The nationalised Chilean mines were kept under state control after the Pinochet’s 1973 Chilean coup d’état, despite the junta’s pro-U.S. leanings and this is still the case, largely because of public sentiment and because Codelco is a major contributor to the Chilean Exchequer. Codelco pays income tax, all dividends go to the government and it also pays a 10% tax on the export value of copper products and associated byproducts according to Law 13,136.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilean_nationalization_of_copper
If foreign owned companies owned Chile’s Copper mines there would be no 10% tax on Chile’s copper exports helping fund the government.
Second
Imagine what the American stock market would be like if half of our exports were copper like Chile and went from less than 2835.4 a ton in 2002 to 9442.3 a ton thats more than a 3 times price increase.
“Chile’s economy is based on the export of minerals, which account for about half of the total value of exports. Copper is the nation’s most valuable resource, and Chile is the world’s largest producer”
http://www.infoplease.com/ce6/world/A0857288.html
http://my.firedoglake.com/thingscomeundone/2011/09/10/privatize-ss-now-just-look-at-chile/
Just a few years ago copper prices were low and everyone was laughing at Chile Cain’s SS scheme would tie SS benefits to the market which means in a bad economy when you need cash the most your benefits would go down.
Plus Chile’s plan is actually quite socialist but of course he is to dumb to realize that.
Go to the diaries :)
Believe it or not revolution is part of the plan. they want mass chaos from which they will create their new world, and there will be a lot less people living in it.
Gotta go great talk:)
Agreed they want a revolution so they can declare martial law they assume they can win the fight. But nothing is certain.
Out now for real.
all is not lost dr murray sentenced to 4 years…………..
Yes, I was looking through the warped cum-stained lense of Cain, I really didn’t figure Pinochet was responsible for anything positive in Chile.
Hmm seems they have managed to win every other revolution
Just sayin’, If you’d been to Danny’s house, like I have, you’d feel a whole lot better about our chances. I think he has a grenade launcher.
Sounds fair to me.
Chile???? Is that the long skinny country or is that Peru????
“Believe it or not revolution is part of the plan”
Maybe so but if we focus our aim at the proper traitors at least they won’t be around to “enjoy their New World Order”
Sidenote: cleanup any evil “seeds” they left laying around.
My very conservative accountant said just that and surprise he said the only hope he saw was Occupy.
I didn’t bring it up, he did.
Not only it is breach of confidentiality by people in position of authority but it is also evidence of deliberative attempts to exploit the system. To coverup the kind of crime committed by Paulson they have also orchestrated distractions. For example, they framed Elliot Epitzer who was dedicated in going after crooked bankers. They also framed and jailed that hedge funds manager (Raj?) for exchanging some pathetic information. If Raj did in fact commit any crime, it was insignificant compared to the extent of looting and rape perpetrated by Paulson, Bernanke, Gaithner, Jamie Damion, Goldman Sachs and other banksters.
I think everything is entirely the FAULT of lazy ingrate slackers – most of whom are minorities – who can’t be bothered to get a job, probably never shower, and like to poop & have sex in the street.
Leave pristine, innocent Wall St & the vaunted Banks alooooooone!! They are fabulous job creators, and you will hurt their iddle-widdle fweelings if you talk smack about them. kiss kiss grovel grovel…. (yeah: /s).
Whatever… yet another CRIMINAL CROOK who gets away with it bc the 1% are just sitting their with their collective middle finger raised to the 99% going: nyen-nyen… whotcha gonna DO about it, suckahs?????
Vote third party is one option. Just saying…
All anybody at the table needed to do was tell somebody else, and any trades that person did would not be able to be tied back to the tipper.
“Chile is a dagger pointed at the heart of Antarctica.”
—Henry Kissinger
Where do you suppose Bernanke’s secrud bank accounts are?
Hey, it’s no big deal. The statute of limitations on Paulson’s behavior is like 3 hours.
Nancy Pelosi’s husband getting the IPO shares was like Lady Bellomont receiving the looted jewels from Captain Kidd…except the Bellomonts had the sense to decline the ill-gotten gains.