In the couple months since Alabama passed HB 56, among the harshest immigration laws in the nation, they have: a) seen crops rot in the fields because farmers cannot find workers to pick the fruits and vegetables, which has cost the state potentially hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue; b) threatened the water service of potential undocumented immigrants; c) forced charities to seek citizenship papers from their recipients, even though that provision and others have been blocked by multiple courts; d) witnessed frustrated employers speak out about the loss of legal Hispanic workers, who have left the state in droves; e) led to 15% of Hispanic students being afraid to attend school; f) arrested top executives of two automakers, Mercedes-Benz and Honda, who were in the state overseeing their plants there.
That last one has particularly stuck in the craw of the state’s leadership, who fear the carmakers moving out of state in revolt after having their executives arrested for not having their passports with them. The charges against both men were dismissed, but not before some serious embarrassment for the state.
And now, after some state lawmakers and the state Attorney General acknowledged that changes need to be made to the law to avoid what they called “unintended consequences” (actually, they were entirely intended from the premise of creating a immigration police state), Governor Robert Bentley agrees.
Alabama Governor Robert Bentley said on Friday he would work to revise the state’s tough new immigration law following embarrassing incidents of foreign workers being detained because they were not carrying sufficient identification.
Bentley, House Speaker Mike Hubbard and Senate President Pro Tem Del Marsh, said in a statement they do not plan to repeal or weaken the law, widely considered to be the toughest state immigration law in the nation.
“We recognize that changes are needed to ensure that Alabama has not only the nation’s most effective law, but one that is fair and just, promotes economic growth, preserves jobs for those in Alabama legally, and can be enforced effectively and without prejudice,” Bentley said.
Sadly, if it wasn’t for the auto executive arrests, the state leadership would still be in denial about it. The business community clearly told them to fix the law and fix it now. But as the economic consequences mount, this is likely to be a first step to either a de-fanging or just a straight repeal of the law. All it will take is one big business to leave the state and they’ll cave. I’ll bet these guys are begging for the courts to take it out of their hands by finding it unconstitutional, as the Justice Department has argued.
This does offer a window into life in Tea Party America. I hope all those corporate types remember what happened to their donations.



24 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Well, let’s hope the suggestion they use prisoners to harvest the crops has died on the vine (sorry–bad pun.)
It won’t. Prisoners have been used for all kinds of work for as long as I can remember.
Why do I suspect that Alabama’s governor will acknowledge the need to change the immigration law to make it openly racist so no White People ever get arrested by accident.
My question is why were the 2 auto executives stopped in the first place?
Its the new slavery isn’t it?
does Newt have kids? they could pick the crops…
Indeed it is. And it’s not illegal -yet. The prisoners are not going to know anything about picking crops and they certainly won’t be as fast as the usual pickers.
On the bright side, it will give Hollywood screenwriters something to work with.
.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/dec/02/alabama-car-boss-immigration-law
The local police resent foreigners richer than they are the push to get illegals is meant to get Hispanic Immigrants poor ones.
The local police however seem to want to use this law to get the rich foreigners who are acceptable to attack because they are not in the in group.
How can you arrest someone for maybe being illegal if they have a work permit? Does Alabama not accept work permits as valid proof you are here legally?
Alabama use of prisoners for field work creates an indirect way to execute them. As someone who has
picked for own use in the Coachella Valley, I can say it is very strenuous work and few can last. The workers are
welcome in California without the bigotry.
One of them was pulled over because his rental car did not have current tags. He had ID with him (his German id), but not his passport. So the officer was given cause (under the new law) to arrest him. Hey, it’s working!
I wonder if the police followed up with the rental car company to update their tags?
Um, plenty of bigotry to go around, even here in California. Many people resent illegal immigrants’ presence, even if the businesses are happy to exploit them…
edited to add, yeah, our bigotry isn’t officially recognized as law. I see what you are saying now.
Rich foreign guys driving while making more money than the local police its like driving while Black. In this poor economy we can probably expect the police to if not give out tickets to hassle the foreigners in the state.
Me and my friends waited outside my car in a blizzard once while the police took their sweet time to call in a suspected stolen AM car radio they found in my car we were going to a party and were not dressed to be outside long.
Its little games like that which can chase away Alabama’s foreign car makers the police have been playing games like this with no over sight forever.
If the police decide they don’t like you its hard for anyone local pols, reporters etc to stop them.
I’m surprised. I thought the whole point of the law was to drive out the cheap illegal immigrant work pool, so that the PTB would have cover to mandate use of the free prisoner work pool.
And then of course they would need to create even more prisoners, because every One Percenter would rather pay workers nothing, rather than less-than-minimum-wage.
Our Oligarchs are getting sloppy!
So the plan is force out illegals then use prison labor? Do I want my tomatoes picked by prisoners the disease rates for prisoners in America is very high and for antibiotic resistant disease its much higher than the general population.
I am not doubting your thinking I am doubting that Alabama is going to get anyone to buy crops with the ALabama picked by Violent Felons with love label on their crops.
There are guys in prison who think it would be funny to ….. I will leave it to your imagination.
Quick! To the PR phone:
These crops were picked by the I was Lost and now I am Found rehabilitated Felons.
Those alabamians, god bless their hearts!
They will need to increase the prison population to provide enough slaves. Perhaps this is why legal Latinos have left the state. Watch for trumped up charges yielding long sentences for young, healthy, people with agricultural experience.
Book Salon up with Lynn Parramore and Sarah Jaffe’s The 99%: How Occupy Wall Street Movement Is Changing America hosted by Lindsay Beyerstein
It is hard to restrain the racists once you have fired them up. I am sure that there are plenty of Klan descendants who are just itching to put all them non Americans back in their place. They will be disappointed when they find out the whole racist law was just to pander to low information voting bigots to get elected and the real beneficiaries will be the 1% or 0.1% of the ruling elite.
“They will be disappointed when they find out the whole racist law was just to pander to low information voting bigots to get elected and the real beneficiaries will be the 1% or 0.1% of the ruling elite.”
If they could ever figure it out, they would be disappointed. They won’t figure it out. Their racism will not let them figure it out. They are being used just as they have always been used.
Somebody should point out to the governor that if they just throw all the poor people in jail, they can have slavery back again, and everything will work out just dandy except for that burning in hell for eternity bit at the end.
The obvious solution is to abolish all border controls and let in everyone.
I know this might sound sick but there is something heartwarming about reading about racists suffering. That inbred hillbillies are suffering because of their hate driven decisions, is …lovely. Millions lost…great.The possibility of car-makers moving out of state…fantastic. It couldn’t happen to a more deserving bunch of shitheels.
I know what you mean, but remember: there is always a group below those hate-driven racists that suffers even worse. That’s a built-in feature of the system and if you’ve ever been in the Deep South long enough you’ll hear something like this from those hate-driven racists when complaining about how hard their lives are, “But at least I’m a white man.” Followed by nudges, winks and chuckles.