The walls have closed in over the past couple weeks on mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The SEC charged former CEOs and executives at the companies with fraud. California Attorney General Kamala Harris sued them for imformation in a wide-ranging fraud investigation. And now we learn that the FBI is investigating them:
At issue is whether Fannie and Freddie — two of the largest mortgage companies in the country, and the recipients of a major government bailout in September 2008 — misled the public and investors about the relative risk of their loans in the lead up to the financial crisis, the Daily reports. The matter has serious implications, since many allege that mortgage lenders’ enthusiasm for making loans to homeowners with shoddy credit, and banks’ penchant for using those loans as financial instruments, are among the principal reasons for the housing crash and financial crisis.
The SEC’s lawsuit probes much the same question, hitting six former executives at the two companies with charges of security fraud, and accusing them of continuing to hold onto questionable loans even after the magnitude of the risk became clear. Neither company is directly named as a defendant in the SEC’s suit.
The SEC appears to be framing that suit as a response to critics who have accused the agency of going easy on the major banks and financial institutions who played a central role in the financial meltdown, according to The New York Times.
If Fannie and Freddie are guilty of misleading investors, they deserve to pay the penalty. And yet, I do sense more enthusiasm to go after these government sponsored enterprises than to go after the private banking firms which were far more responsible for subprime. This feeds a false narrative that government somehow caused the financial crisis by forcing lending to poor people. Fannie and Freddie followed the market in subprime and did not originate it.
That said, you do need to start somewhere, and if they exhibited criminal behavior, I’m happy to see them pay the price. And of course, getting the FBI involved raises the possibility of criminal charges, whereas the SEC violations were civil.
It’s also good to know that The Daily is still in existence. But it’s a measure of their success, or lack thereof, that nobody found out about this FBI investigation until several days after initial publication.




34 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Fannie and Freddie are far, far less culpable than the private banks. This is merely a ploy to shift blame to them so they can be dismantled. Nothing more.
Sorry, but I’m quite sure this will be the beginning and the end of any criminal investigation into banking fraud. Yet another way of picking the least liked banking entity and letting them be the scapegoat while freeing the rest to go free.
It is like reading about every friggin’ settlement we have heard of and in some cases actually had. They are merely exercises in protecting the owners/CEOs/Boards of Directors and have nothing to do with justice and fairness and enforcing the laws.
So, I am not happy about this as it is one piece of hamburger thrown to the seething masses when they deserve a semi full of steak. And since some of the masses will be soothed and others can now be lectured about how the bad actors were dealt with, I would rather it not happen at all. I want all the bankster criminals to be perp walked into the privately owned prisons they loved so much. This just means that two or three people will get a slap on the wrist and the others will buy yachts. If they were serious, BofA wouldn’t have settled for defrauding minorities yesterday, we would be talking trials. Even better, in typical MOTU fashion, their chosen scapegoat will mean that if you want to buy a home you better be one of them. And not once do they think how that will cripple their profits and options in the future.
Agree.
I want to see when the Fibbies do something real, like go after the Goldman Sucks. I won’t hold my breath.
This is yet another Kabuki Show. Today’s Act is entitled:
Wherein the Feebs are directed to ’round up the usual suspects’ – aka teh poorz and teh minorities – in order to scapegoat them and make it really really really look they are to blame for the nation being run into the shitter. If Fannie & Freddie can be dismantled in the process: a two-fer WIN! Of course, Newt Gingrich does not have to give back his Fannie & Freddie payola because: a) IOKIYAR, and b) he was learnin’ ‘em some of that thar history-stuff.
Scott Paltrow weighs in on the lack of federal investigations and prosecutions, though he does summarize state efforts (without mentioning Schneiderman):
Special Report: The watchdogs that didn’t bark
“The federal government, as has been widely noted, has pressed few criminal cases against major lenders or senior executives for the events that led to the meltdown of 2007. Finding hard evidence has proved difficult, the Justice Department has said.
“The government also hasn’t brought any prosecutions for dubious foreclosure practices deployed since 2007 by big banks and other mortgage-servicing companies.
“But this part of the financial system, a Reuters examination shows, is filled with potential leads.”
LINK.
Just watched ‘Inside Job’ for 2nd time last night. Charles Ferguson’s film. Won documentary Oscar. It’s about the Crash, how it happened, who skated and who got screwed. Should be mandatory viewing.
DD wrote: “And yet, I do sense more enthusiasm to go after these government sponsored enterprises than to go after the private banking firms which were far more responsible…”
——————
Noticed that, did ya’??? Me too. What could possibly explain that????
Agreed.
So much for the President’s acclaimed ability to master the political landscape via his “11th dimension” purview.
Validating the “Big Lie” is tantamount to political suicide.
I find I’m reminded of the infamous episode of “The Simpsons” where Springfield is threatened with destruction from a meteor. The residents of Springfield descend into “Lord of the Flies” mania only to be saved by the accident of selfishness. In response to the “threat” of meteoric annihilation, the citizen mob rushes off to destroy Springfield’s observatory to protect themselves from the future threat of meteors.
As for Obama, his citizenry is still bereft of ~$14 trillion in home asset value destroyed – a sum known to many individual home-owners as their retirement nest egg.
Why aren’t they investigating this?
http://wakeupfromyourslumber.blogspot.com/2009/04/freddie-mac-apparent-suicide-i-think.html
http://www.askbutwhy.com/2009/04/freddie-mac-cfo-david-kellerman-dead-by.html
http://forum.prisonplanet.com/index.php?topic=100910.35;wap2
or this?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_I._Levy
When you need big time cover for an inside job, call the FIB…I mean FBI.
Just ask William C. Sullivan. Oh, I forgot. He’s dead from a hunting accident.
They’re not called MOTU for nothing.
Or better, “The Flaw” which, unfortunately, never found a distributor and as a result was only screened in limited venues mainly film festivals.
There are SOME states AG’s that are pursuing this. UNdoubtedly for political gain. But, I’m willing to let the ends justify the means in this case.
I’m really a “glass half full” kind a guy.
Obama is to accountability as “7-Up” is to cola.
blue, The FBI and the SEC are busy people. Lots of laws to enforce, lots of criminal to catch.
THey have to remember which laws they aren’t enforcing and which people they aren’t eforcing them against.
According to one well-known authority, with the addition of Kamala Harris, there are now five that appear to be pursuing in earnest:
“The lawsuits in foreclosure fraud all have their own specialized nature. Martha Coakley has taken on the big banks for stealing homes. Beau Biden sued MERS. Eric Schneiderman is focusing on securitization. Catherine Cortez Masto charged LPS with systematic document fraud. And now Harris has targeted Fannie and Freddie.”
LINK.
A round of drinks for my friends here, Martha, Cathy, Beau and Eric. Oh, and my buddy here for his damn fine research. We’re gonna make the phrase “We the People” mean something again.
“Cut, Print”
That was good.
I’m sorry, some may see this as a good thing, I don’t. Anytime the Feds get involved with these financial investigations, it usually means the crooks get off with no jail time, and having only to pay a meaningless fine. So, no this isn’t good news to me. If it were a State AG I’d be much more optimistic. Nothing the Feds will do a damned thing to help the homeowners they defrauded. The fine will go to the SEC for government use, and the homeowners are still sleeping on the street.
Two interesting things here. One, the Fed has been using FM/FM as a special purpose vehicle to dispose of toxic CDO’s that the banks were sold. So I wonder how deep this rabbit hole goes.
Secondly, all the major banks and lenders were using FM/FM as a butter churn to froth up their house of cards scams they had been cooking up since at least 2000. If executives in the GSE’s get bitch slapped, I’d be looking for them to turn over on the REAL criminals in BofA, Countrywide, Citi, WaMu, etc. That would be good news indeed.
Fannie and Freddie, big government at its finest
You idiot. FM/FM have nothing to do with BIG GOVERNMENT. They are private for profit corporations with an ‘implicit’ government backing. Privatized profits and socialized losses at its finest!
government backing…..socialized losses……listen to yourself. What do you think that means? BIG GOVERMENT! That government backing fueled the housing cresis. Open your eyes.
Okay, let’s try this again, a company listed in NYSE is not a government agency. When Fannie was created back in the 30′s it was a well run government agency. The government divested itself of these and Freddie evolved as a sister org (COMPLETELY FROM A PRIVATE CORP) years and years ago in the late 60′s and 70′s. They functioned as staid and boring organizations until the meth-headed wall street greed machine got involved. The only reason this contraption could even exist is due to revolving door regulators captured by corrupt PRIVATE banks. And you better thank your lucky stars they exist in this form in a way, or all the fucking banks would have collapsed. The Fed (ANOTHER PRIVATE BANK) has effectively turned FM and FM into the ‘bad bank’ to dispose of these colossal losses fucking idiots running the PRIVATE BANKS created.
Don’t you think anything that sheds light on this is a good thing, in the long run.
I like the way you think. I feel anything that is done can’t hurt. I’m also a vindictive kind of guy too. It’s fun. Give it a try.
When the government guarantees loans made by Fannie and Freddie it is no longer a private entity, its an arm of the government. Does not make a difference where the company is listed. Its pretty straightforward. Not sure why you don’t understand it. Though I expect its crystal clear to you but the truth intrudes on your cradle to grave mentality so its hard to admit.
@ Sinestar, I agree with everything that you say. But, let’s be nice. We’re all on the same team here.
I agree with everything that you say. But, let’s be nice. We’re all on the same team here.
The, IMO, biggest case in process right now no one has mentioned yet. TIAA/Cref (mostly teacher retirement funds manager) is suing GS for fraud and to recover all losses stemming from being convinced to buy CDS’s et al. They have an internal e-mail calling the investment shit at the same time one of their people sent a letter to Cref saying what a safe bet it was. Civil court and money damages are the only way to punish GS et al because they have the Federal Govt in their pocket. State sponsored Capitalism is Fascism.
A slight bit OT but Fitch is threatening a downgrade of US bonds.
John McGraw owns S&P and this .01%er owns Fitch
The World’s Billionaires
#432 Marc Ladreit de Lacharrière
03.08.07, 6:00 PM ET
Age: 66
Fortune: self made
Source: Finance
Net Worth: $2.2 bil
Country Of Citizenship: France
Residence: Paris , France, Europe & Russia
Industry: Finance
Marital Status: divorced, 4 children
Education: Ecole Nationale d’Administration
Chief executive of Fimalac, parent of Fitch Ratings, which operates in 50 countries. Founded the company in 1991 after a varied career. Started a teen magazine in 1961 at age 21. Sold it off a few years later. Attended elite Ecole Nationale d’Administration, then moved into banking and finance. Eventually landed at L’Oréal, where he spent 15 years, rising up to group executive vice president of finance. Now a board member at L’Oréal and Renault. A theater buff, he has helped fund renovations for the Theatre du Rond Point in Paris. Is also on the board of the American Friends of the Louvre.
Thank you for that. I have been wondering who would name their company TIAA/CREF for years.
Oh, and I applaud anybody who sues GS for anything. You go girls!!!!
Yeah sure hippie guy. You are entitled to your own opinion, but not your own facts. What ever happened to the expression “the truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off”?
Fact is the regime played a huge, drivers seat role in creating the subprime disaster. Wallstreet merely went along for the ride knowing that their bought and paid for tools in the regime would ensure that they got away scott free.
From H.U.D. policy to Federal reserve malfeasance in suppressing interest rates, the financial ‘crisis’ was a government sponsored enterprise. Be ignorant if you like, it is after all sort of a kinda free country still, don’t you ever feel the temptation to know the actual truth though?
After all it would set you free.
——-
Rahm Emanuel Dumped Tons Of Freddie Mac Stock Days Before It …
http://www.economicpolicyjournal.com/…/rahm-emanuel-dumped-tons-of-..
Nov 14, 2011 – Rahm Emanuel Dumped Tons Of Freddie Mac Stock Days Before It Collapsed. In a new book, Throw Them All Out,Peter Schwiezer reports that …
oh shit, newcar. beats me. (not)