I wrote Saturday about the Christmas drone truce, a six-week pause in aerial bombing of suspected terrorists over Pakistan, in reaction to a botched airstrike that killed 24 soldiers. Now it looks like this gesture of goodwill (as if “we won’t bomb your country” should be interpreted that way) will not salvage a robust security relationship, but simply allow the US to get kicked out more gracefully.
With the United States facing the reality that its broad security partnership with Pakistan is over, American officials are seeking to salvage a more limited counterterrorism alliance that they acknowledge will complicate their ability to launch attacks against extremists and move supplies into Afghanistan.
The United States will be forced to restrict drone strikes, limit the number of its spies and soldiers on the ground and spend more to transport supplies through Pakistan to allied troops in Afghanistan, American and Pakistani officials said. United States aid to Pakistan will also be reduced sharply, they said.
“We’ve closed the chapter on the post-9/11 period,” said a senior United States official, who requested anonymity to avoid antagonizing Pakistani officials. “Pakistan has told us very clearly that they are re-evaluating the entire relationship.”
This is an interesting admission from that senior US official, basically acknowledging that, for ten years, Pakistan was a client state, with relatively open borders for US counter-terrorism forces who had impunity to do whatever they wanted. Surprisingly, the public appreciated this relationship less and less, the more they saw it escalate. And the Pakistani government, fearing they would lose their own careers, if not their heads, in the process, is in the process of terminating that client-state relationship or scaling it back sharply.
You can divine all you need to know about this relationship, in that one of the first step will be to scale back the “kill boxes,” areas along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border where CIA drones are allowed to kill with impunity. Kill boxes! I can’t imagine how that would incite hatred or cause a problem for the sovereign government.
Indeed, just this weekend, over 100,000 Pakistanis rallied with Imran Khan, the former cricketer turned politician, who has gained political fame by criticizing the relationship with the US.
This was always going to collapse. You cannot treat another country like a target range without there being some recriminations. The country in question just happens to have nuclear weapons and seething anger. Well done, everyone.




26 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
“cannot use another country as a target range…” w/o expecting blowback..
well, DUH!!!
Ah, they just hate us for our (vanishing) freedoms. Just like everyone else.
Imagine that… you bomb the shit out of their citizens with robots for ten fucking years and they want to up and end the “security relationship”…. Buncha ingrates.
/s
Finally!
Excellent, informative piece, David. Recc’d. It’s not that hard to understand one reason why there were powerful voices in both the Bush and Obama Administrations. It’s both misunderstanding of history and hubris on their part. Their thinking goes something like this:
“The Indus Valley region, now called Pakistan, has been ruled or manipulated by foreign powers for millennia. Hell, it was part of India and ruled by the British until 1947! We can manipulate those little brown people just like the British did, only better, because we’re Americans. Bribe the right people. Divide not just on class and ethnic lines like the British did, but figure out how to manipulate Islamic sects to fight each other and then who cares how many of those Muslim maniacs kill each other?”
There’s several huge problems with that way of thinking. It’s definite Eurocentric arrogance, for one thing. It’s American Exceptionalism for another, and anti-Middle-eastern and anti-South Asian racism on top of that. It severely underestimates the intelligence of the majority of people who live in both Pakistan and India, as well as Iran, Afghanistan, Iraq and other countries in the region.
American manipulation of the Pakistani government and economy over the last decade has been both crude and obvious. Then we start killing their soldiers with our weapons, carry out a humiliating assassination next to a Pakistani Army base, and then we turn around and criticize THEM(I include Pakistani Muslim culture here as well) for violating human rights!
In short, going back to the withdrawal by the British, and insanely accelerating over the last ten years, the United States Government and its corporate partners have been embarked on the course most likely to really piss tens of millions of people whose government has nuclear weapons off at America.
Indeed, well done!
“Brought to you by the Heritage Foundation, where, for your convenience, we put arrogance and stupidity into the same package!”
In reference to # 5
You said it all.
Dont forget that Imran Khan (the cricketer) is not an angel. Would be puppet.
Oh good! Now we can close the chapter on the Patriot Act (and its spawn).
That nicely sums up the Heritage Foundation!
Onward to Africa? (You know they aren’t going to give up warring.)
Al-Qaida leadership almost wiped out in Pakistan, British officials believe
Senior members of al-Qaida are feared to be moving to north Africa to open up a new front after being weakened in Pakistan
LINK.
Margaret, I don’t think anyone would not recognize that as snark.
Oh, I’m sure they’ll get right to that as soon as Congress gets back./s Hope you had a good holiday, gw.
greenwarrior, you wouldn’t possibly be writing snark would you? ;-)
“Brought to you by the Heritage Foundation, where, for your convenience, we put arrogance and stupidity into the same package!”
I do believe the Heritage Foundation would be willing to pay you for the right to use that slogan.
realitychecker, what do you mean “vanishing” freedoms? Our Constitutional freedoms are as firmly fixed as SS and Medicare. We will be thanking w and dick for developing the “patriot” act and ryan and 0 for ‘saving’ SS and Medicare, and 0 and the congress for the ndaa to disappear us.
would be and am! very sorry to say.
Ever since the demise of the USSR as a world power, the mindset of the US military has been that they can easily treat any other country like a target range, with complete impunity. In the past, this mindset has been supported by the unquestionable superiority of US missle and bomber technology.
It’s now becoming obvious that the technological superiority that created the attitude of impunity is crumbling away. It remains to be seen how long the attitude of impunity will continue in the absence of its former support.
I have frequently wished I could just disappear, but I always wanted it to be by my own choice. :-(
Seriously, the Bill of Rights as I studied it in law school in the early 1980′s does not exist anymore. I am amazed at how few people I speak to have any appreciation of that truth. Or interest in learning about it.
it’s been a difficult couple a weeks, buddy. i’ve had pains in my ear and head. last week i saw a massage therapist, a traditional chinese medical doctor, and an md. this coming week, i’ve got an appointment with an osteopath and hope to make more appointments with a dentist and a neurologist and a ear-nose-throat doc. and maybe for good measure another md. it being the week between christmas and new year’s doesn’t mean it’ll be any too easy.
the tcm doc and the massage therapist thought it was tension in the neck and shoulder, but it got worse after the massage therapist and didn’t change after the tcm doc. the md thought it was trigeminal neuralgia, which i’d never heard of, but i don’t know if i buy that. she said to see a neurologist. someone i know who’s had trigeminal neuralgia doesn’t think that i have it and she’s the one who suggested a dentist and an ent doc. she said her neurologist years ago in new york told her it’s often misdiagnosed.
i’ve been a busy little girl doing what helps to relieve pain and gathering recommendations for doctors and a dentist. when i looked at the side effects from the pain meds the md prescribed i turned them back in at the pharmacy and got my money back.
in the meantime, whether it’s diet, refusing to leave the house and cranking the temperature up to sauna level (heat is definitely helping) or it just deciding to torture me less, the pain isn’t as severe as it originally was.
this may well be too much information.
in any case, i hope your holidays have given you pleasure.
Really where are the flowers?
Oh, gw, I’m so sorry you are going thru all that. FWIW, I am a big believer in gentle massage and heat for many physical problems. Don’t worry about TMI, sweetie, I deal with a truckload of issues from accumulated wounds and injuries every day. People who care about you expect you to be honest about what your reality is. ((gw))
thanks, hon. it feels good to hear you say it.
Pardon me for being on topic –
Excellent, DDayen. Whereas the MSM dumps on Pakistan you get closer to the truth, which is that U.S. and Pakistan security interests never coincided, in fact they conflict.
I think that slogan originated with Newt “The Lizard” Gingrich, though Trump claims it was his and he lost it in a bankruptcy filing.
So, who’s career has been ended by this? A question I should ask of my Senator Feinstein when she’s back in the office.
The first step toward shape-shifting the entire war effort to Iran was spoiled when the Iranians apparently over-rode command-and-control signals (emanating from upstate NY) and landed the stealth drone intact. It’s our drone and we can drop bombs on whomsoever we desire, regardless of international borders. Nothing would firm up the rule of the ayatollahs more than a few bombs dropped courtesy of the US, stupid ingrates!
Puppet of who?