Wired is censored today. So is TBogg’s mini-site. The Google doodle is blacked out. And part of Daily Kos. And a lead story at The Huffington Post. And even right here. Sites like Wikipedia and Reddit and I Can Haz Cheezburger and Raw Story and Informed Comment and thousands more are completely dark today, not providing any content. It’s part of the largest online strike in history.
This all protests the Stop Online Piracy Act and the Protect IP Act, two dangerous pieces of anti-piracy legislation that would allow for official censorship of Websites through an “Internet blacklist,” and possibly disrupt the very architecture of the Internet. Ron Wyden, who has been against the bill from the beginning, offers a general explanation:
RW: I said, from the beginning, that first, there’s a problem here. There’s no question that people who sell fake Rolexes or tainted Viagra or movies they don’t own are bad actors. Second, there’s a straightforward solution, which is to cut off the money that gets people into piracy. But third, to solve this problem by doing damage to the Internet, which has been a juggernaut for job growth and innovation and free speech, is a mistake. So that was our argument: There’s a problem, there’s a remedy, but you don’t need a cluster bomb to solve it.
The bill would put the burden of proof on the Web site to police its content for copyright or risk being taken down. It would allow for the cutoff of payments and the shutdown of Web sites without a court hearing or a trial. It would give private companies the ability to sue to take down sites they feel violate their copyright. Before last weekend, it would have allowed the Justice Department to require ISPs to block certain domain names, damaging the secure standard of the Domain Name System. The House version of this bill eliminated that provision, but it remains in the Senate version, with Chairman Patrick Leahy – who is very tied in with the entertainment industry – seeking only to “study” the provision before implementation.
Despite a string of victories on the bills over the past several weeks, the grassroots coalition and Internet giants pushing against this bill have not rested. They turned the legislation from inevitable to a situation where House Majority Leader Eric Cantor said he would not bring the bill to the floor without “consensus.” But Lamar Smith, the Chair of the House Judiciary Committee, said he would complete the markup on SOPA in February. And the Senate will still hold a vote on the bill next week. So there’s every reason to garner more attention for this awful piece of legislation, which would for the first time in America censor the Internet in ways that we’ve seen in repressive regimes during the Arab uprising.
The anti-SOPA coalition has already done something special, however. They have moved this bill from inevitable to an open question. And they even got Dianne Feinstein to try and broker a deal:
In December, HuffPost reported that Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), a Protect IP co-sponsor with deep ties to both Hollywood and the technology industry, thought disputes between two of her most prominent corporate constituencies had been worked out. After that story ran, Feinstein attempted to broker a compromise, calling both tech companies and film studios.
Walt Disney Co. President and CEO Bob Iger declined the invitation on behalf of content providers. “Hollywood did not feel that a meeting with Silicon Valley would be productive at this time,” said a spokesperson. The meeting took place with only tech companies present. Feinstein, once a reliable vote for the existing version of Protect IP, is now working hard to amend the bill, according to Senate Democratic aides.
But finding common ground is more difficult in this case than in most intra-corporate squabbles, because the two sides — or powerful elements within them, at least — have largely irreconcilable world views. One senior Senate aide said that the technology side consistently refuses to specify precise changes they want to the bill. Indeed, improving the bill would be counterproductive if the ultimate goal is killing it outright — which it certainly is for many elements of the anti-SOPA coalition.
“That’s a high-stakes risk,” said the senior aide, “because if they don’t have 41 votes, then what?”
DiFi isn’t the only Senator wavering. Ben Cardin, a co-sponsor, now opposes PIPA (the Senate version of the bill) in its current form. Jeff Merkley and Mark Udall and Scott Brown came out against it. Harry Reid doesn’t want to move the initial cloture vote, set for next Tuesday, but at this rate, it may not get the 60 votes needed to advance. And even if it does, Wyden and Sen. Jerry Moran plan to spend hours in a “talking filibuster” discussing the dangers of the bill on the Senate floor.
By taking down or “censoring” their sites, the groups involved ask their audiences to call Congress and stop the legislation. This is a left-right, transpartisan coalition, best exemplified by Vote for the Net, a partnership between Demand Progress and former Democratic Congressional candidate David Segal, and Don’t Censor the Net and former RNC media director Patrick Ruffini. They have over 33,000 names on this pledge:
In 2012, I will only support candidates who stand for Internet freedom and who oppose the PROTECT IP Act and SOPA. I will work against any candidate, of any party, who votes to censor and stifle the Internet.
They are also collecting donations for the first four Senators who vowed to fight the anti-piracy bills: Wyden, Moran, Rand Paul and Maria Cantwell. Of the four, only Cantwell faces re-election this year.
Online activism has foundered somewhat in the post-Obama era. But this push to stop these anti-piracy bills, bringing together the innovation of the Internet with the force of grassroots organizing, have set a model for how to do 21st-century politics. Of course, having a clutch of massive Internet sites on your side doesn’t hurt.




25 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Murdock’s war on truth. Will any of us outlive that mother fucker?
I have nothing to say.Cancer… Somethings you just don’t compromise with…
Okay, I know the argument is somewhere and I’ve read it, but if you make a movie for 50 million dollars, how do you get the money back? Or is this part of working towards a non market society where we find a way to make the same movie by all pooling our resources and then all enjoy it? You know, the modern day equivalent of sitting around the fire telling stories after finding berries and eating a rabbit, mending our clothes and making sure the roof doesn’t leak.
I even blocked out my little site.
Maybe the movie industry is just too big and obscene. 50 million for a crap movie? Entertainment has become more important than freedom. (I haven’t been to a movie in 5 years.)
The New and Improved Nazi America.
That’s where we’re at after this .
Heil all !
If you had to pay a royalty for every unoriginal idea, plot, scene, image or joke, you’d never be able to make it in the first place, would you?
http://www.craigslist.org/about/SOPA
Craigslist has a great page/links on SOPA/PIPA
The Affordable Care Act should have disavowed people of any hope that Obama would bring change to the oligarchy. Democrats went to sleep after Viet Nam, now they’re firmly entrenched in the status quo. One thing about firedoglake, it’s activists haven’t given up.
Never. Give. Up.
Occupy much? Occupy wouldn’t have happened with out a strong online community.
Given a choice of libertarism and increasing flawed legislation, I choose the lesser of two evils.
I challenge all FDL pups to perform just 1 act of civil disobedience this year.
Make a sign and post it. Or???
Please share your ideas on this thread.
We have more than two choices. We just have to make them. I am not voting in this country until I have a real choice. A polished turd in not better than one that does not shine.
One doesn’t have to perform an act of civil disobedience to be effective. Talking to neighbors, co-workers, etc is effective. The object is to make people aware of the inequities and injustice of current policies.
Marymccumin,
By not voting you are decreasing voter turnout which helps to elect Republicans – your decision not to vote is only logical if you are a conservative.
You’re correct, SD. I have a righty coworker who is now a lefty after many political discussions we’ve had.
Vote for Rocky Anderson…
SouthernDragon,
I’m totally with you on talking to your friends, neighbors and acquaintances.
I still think doing an act of civil disobedience gets the juices flowing, it helps put the pressure on the PTB.
Nonviolence is the best way to kickstart the revolution.
Hanging a sign is Just another method of talking to friends, neighbors and coworkers, and people you don’t even know.
“I want all of you to get up out of your chairs and walk over to the window and yell: I’m mad as hell and I’m not gonna take this anymore.”
Stop SOPA and PIPA, an 8 minute video on rawstory to brighten your day and maybe even get some motivated to move.
http://www.rawstory.com/
Freedom of speech rocks!
Voting for pols is just voting for the 1% which I won’t ever do again. I will still go and got vote for amendments and proposals though.
Craig’s List has a good page on SOPA and PIPA and it is blocked to users except for numerous links to good info and politicians’ sites to send them a message.
For the record, I oppose both SOPA and PIPA. The Motion Picture industry makes it fairly difficult to copy their stuff. If you have the time and inclination though you can pirate. But from what I have read, these technology illiterate bills will not stop such infringements. Instead we get a junk bill that will make it hard for innovating at a basic level. I don’t even think the Motion Picture business really would want to stop a free internet. They must get all kinds of ideas for free as well as information that makes it easier to make a movie. I don’t think this was thought through or……
So what is really going on? The recurring question: Evil or Stupid?
More reading at redd.it blog.reddit.com/2012/01/technical-examination-of-sopa-and.html
Kudos to Andy Mabbett in Birmingham, England for this petition to the UK government that all UK folks can sign and that citizens of other central governments can consider putting forward to theirs.
“Protect IP, SOPA protests knock Senate Web sites offline” (CNET.Com, by Declan McCullagh, January 18, 2012 12:36 PM PST)
Avaaz about to pass 1.5 million signers for #wikipediablackout.
Updates:
More at https://twitter.com/#!/search/wikipediablackout and #SOPAStrike.