The people who at least have a line into the national conversation inform me that this potential foreclosure fraud settlement is more than a drill. I’m hearing what Yves Smith is hearing. The meeting next Monday will attempt to bully Democratic AGs to back up their President in an election year. As Marcy Wheeler writes, the meeting will take place in Chicago, the home of the Obama campaign headquarters. I assume that at least some campaign officials will be in attendance.
None of the named principles of this discussion live in Chicago. Thomas Perelli is in DC. Shawn Donovan is in DC. Tom Miller is in IA. Even the banksters are from NY and Charlotte.
The one thing that’s in Chicago, of course, is Obama’s campaign headquarters. (Outgoing Chief of Staff and now campaign Co-Chair and former–future?–JP Morgan exec Bill Daley? He lives in Chicago!)
So to “solve” the foreclosure problem, we’re going to invite a bunch of people–but only the Democrats–to Obama’s campaign headquarter city to hammer out something that really only helps a fraction of those affected.
It’s entirely possible that this is an effort to create the appearance of momentum where none exists. After all, it wasn’t but a week ago that Democratic AGs met among themselves to map out a universe without a settlement. But whether it is members of HUD or Obama for America or DoJ, they will put the full-court pressure on the AGs, assuming everyone shows up (I’m in the midst of confirming that).
Let’s take a step back, then, and explain who these people pushing for a settlement are. Reuters has a helpful primer on this today.
U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and Lanny Breuer, head of the Justice Department’s criminal division, were partners for years at a Washington law firm that represented a Who’s Who of big banks and other companies at the center of alleged foreclosure fraud, a Reuters inquiry shows.
The firm, Covington & Burling, is one of Washington’s biggest white shoe law firms. Law professors and other federal ethics experts said that federal conflict of interest rules required Holder and Breuer to recuse themselves from any Justice Department decisions relating to law firm clients they personally had done work for [...]
Reuters reported in December that under Holder and Breuer, the Justice Department hasn’t brought any criminal cases against big banks or other companies involved in mortgage servicing, even though copious evidence has surfaced of apparent criminal violations in foreclosure cases [...]
A particular concern by those pressing for an investigation is Covington’s involvement with Virginia-based MERS Corp, which runs a vast computerized registry of mortgages. Little known before the mortgage crisis hit, MERS, which stands for Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, has been at the center of complaints about false or erroneous mortgage documents.
The 1% protects the 1%. That’s all we’re talking about here. The problem for the Administration is that millions of homeowners have paid the price for this protection racket, and there’s an election coming up. So the effort will be made to create a fig leaf of a “solution” to “fix” the housing market and benefit homeowners. We’ve already run the numbers here. Shaun Donovan said the settlement will help 1 million homeowners and 10.7 million are underwater. The settlement has, at most, $20 billion for principal reduction (probably a lot less), averaging out to $20,000 per homeowner, when the average underwater amount is anywhere between $52,000 and $84,000. This is an inadequate settlement, even more so when you recognize that the banks would only have to hit a dollar amount rather than a number of borrowers, meaning that they’ll focus on the biggest houses and reduce the number of people getting relief.
There have been no real investigations to probe the extent of the fraud. Previous deals with the promise of loan modifications in exchange for a settlement resulted in the banks not doing the mods and actively harming the borrowers. And yet there’s this illusion of “momentum” to move forward.
Lots of groups are protesting this. Working America, the community-based affiliate of the AFL-CIO, has a petition up. The Campaign for America’s Future has been working on this as well. There’s still time for Democratic AGs to hold out for a legitimate settlement that doesn’t give away massive liability in exchange for a pittance.




48 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I am appalled by this. Obama’s Attorney General is linked to the legal “justification” of MERS. How do you justify usurping 236 years (based upon a thousand years in England) of land transfer law?
This explains EVERYTHING! I wonder if the Republicans will spin this to bring Obama down? Does this give cover for the poor innocent banks, just following their lawyer’s advice, Obama’s AG’s advice?
Did Reuters give Obama a heads up? Is that why his campaign office is hosting a meeting on this?
Or worse,…does no one really care?
“U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and Lanny Breuer, head of the Justice Department’s criminal division, were partners for years at a Washington law firm that represented a Who’s Who of big banks and other companies at the center of alleged foreclosure fraud, a Reuters inquiry shows.”
—————–
Well, THAT’S more thana little troubling.
People need to speak out more effectively. Just voting once, or twice every four years isn’t enough by a longshot. On my way back down from Seattle now, finding most of my signs from the way up still standing… like three quarters of them. Here’s Sacramento:
http://freewayblogger.blogspot.com/2012/01/sacramento-california.html
Money isn’t free speech. But this is.
Talk about incestuous relationships. JHFC on a crutch. Holder’s as corrupt as John Mitchell. Assholes.
Elections are for suckers. Merely the fraudulent veneer of what passes for “democracy.”
The French had it right. So did the Roumanians. When will we ever get it right?
I think I have come pretty damn close to becoming an Anarchist, and I would be one if I could figure out what an Anarchist is, beyond being a person who is so fed up that he wants to blow everything up and start over. Although that sounds about as good a response as any other to our situation.
Where is Martha when we need her?
So, they’re holding this seance in Chicago so the little man with the dock walloper’s vocabulary can practice his tantrum routine?
You’re doing fine work, friend. Keep spreading the word.
This government is corrupt from top to bottom.
I used to be very engaged in the political process. These days I just can’t do it. Burned out. My comments are minimal. My brain doesn’t have the capacity to think things through any longer. I keep thinking things will get better in my own head, but all I want to do is take walks and eat.
Amen. Reform from within is not possible because everyone is tainted.
Reform can only come from without. Occupy is laying the foundation.
Oh, it gets better in regards to the current DOJ:
Now why would he feel it necessary to do that?
I will have to go with tasteoffreedom at #11, we’re being ruled by corrupt thugs at every level.
Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time and pay the fine.
Each fraudulent document filed is a separate criminal offense, and these fools should be sentenced accordingly. The laws should be “faithfully executed.” That way we can “move forward” with dignity and with oaths of office intact.
FWB, and I capitalize that out of respect for you.
Thank you for ALL you are doing to make people aware of what is going on.
I am afraid that not many people pay attention to how everything going on is affecting their lives, but they cannot miss your signs on their way to and from their workplace.
You are a gem!!!
I don’t believe Holder, Obama or any of these folks are “conflicted”. They know exactly who and what they are working towards.
Just signed Working America petition and added that Holder and Breuer should recuse themselves, resign be fired or impeached. Of course modern US politics is an ethics and responsibility free zone.
The American justice system which is inherently part of the political system has become the domain of mealy mouthed individuals whose only concern is their personal gain. This is not just an American problem but a world problem. Societies based on greed cannot survive.
The take over a Zero Hedge.
http://www.zerohedge.com/contributed/obama-pushes-hard-protect-big-banks-fraud-prosecutions-we-can-stop-him
If the state AG’s cave the banksters get a pass, luckily for the president is running against a party that is complicit in the further obstruction of justice. We have to hope this drags on past the election. If 0 wins there is a slight possibility holder could be replaced and then possibly accountability..
This will be off a backdrop of what the economics of the next 8 months are and the price of oil. The hopeful resurgence of OWS in the spring.
One thing is a fact holder is there through the election.
“The settlement has, at most, $20 billion for principal reduction (probably a lot less), averaging out to $20,000 per homeowner, when the average underwater amount is anywhere between $52,000 and $84,000.”
Where in the world are you getting numbers? The average underwater is published as around $35,000 – God knows what the median is as it is not published.
And the number as presented is not on point, esp.since the number needed is not available. The needed number is the number covered by the settlement and the amount of principle that is reduced for each, meaning those with both the ability to pay the reduced amount, and for whom a reduced amount would be available.
But then BS used to stop the settlement is likely to just make it more likely, which in my opinion is a good result.
Susan, the business news writer calling herself Yves Smith, has in my opinion little expertize or credibility. She says “The big argument made in favor of the deal, that it will help borrowers, is patently false”, ignoring the over 400,000 principal reductions that have been done. Granted it is not enough, and is less than promised in at least Countrywide’s case, as one can see in the Nevada Court suit, but “patently false”?
I join with you in thinking the $20 billion should be $30 or $40 billion so as to cover 75% of those able and willing to pay the needed payment after the principle reduction – but to oppose the settlement means we get no principle reduction and no help for the economy for many years, with the only winners the hedge funds that bought mortgage backed securities a year ago at 35 cents on the dollar and now demand 100% be paid to them via a put back.
Indeed those hedge funds are trying to do the same thing with the Greek debt, trying to destroy the agreement on a haircut to the bonds.
What side is the US Left on? – Is it the 1% crowd that runs the hedge funds?
the 0bummer kabuki show marches on.
IF their opponent is Romney, they need to steal as much as they can cuz Romney is probably going to beat 0bummer, and then Romney’s friends will get to steal more than 0bummer’s friends are allowed to steal.
IF their opponent is Newt-Palin-nut-Du-Jour, they might was well steal all they can cuz after Tues. 6 November the clock starts ticking on how much longer they have to steal.
At least with the fascist Raygun-Cheney regimes:
1. I EXPECTED them to lie so they could steal … (duh … what the fuck were they supposed to do? tell the truth!)
2. I did NOT vote for the lying thieving bastards.
I can’t think of much interesting happening this year, other than:
1. how many Democratic sell out yuppie scum FINALLY get thrown out on their asses,
2. what is turnout.
rmm
Is this what Jefferson feared? Private banks, inflation deflation, market manipulations energy, banks and corporations depriving people of property and people and families waking up homeless? Do Americans have protection from corporate? Scott needed protection from slave-owners. He was ignored. Call it going backwards?
Chump change. Someone needs to tell these arrogant pricks to go pound sand…and don’t come back until they have an offer that is (at the very least) not a slap-in-the-face insult.
Chicago? Seriously? I wonder if Rahm will be there to offer plenty of insults and expletives?
These sonsabitches are starting to irritate me…
I don’t think the headline of this article is accurate. Being “massively conflicted” makes me think that their are contrary views within the Justice Department, NOT that they have “massive conflicts of interest” which apparently these 2 leaders of the Dept. do.
Well, at least now we know why they and the entire Obama administration are dismissive and defensive concerning their complete lack of responsibility and accountability in investigating and prosecuting the frauds. And I, for one, wish that the President would stop saying repeatedly that what happened was unethical and immoral but not illegal.
The person who suggested special prosecutors is completely right. American homeowners and taxpayers will see no justice from this administration.
Well, while I am not a spokesman for “the left”, I do get annoyed at the tendency for our party to take shitty deals. I want convictions–massive, numerous and totally ruinous convictions of these criminals. I want all their wealth confiscated, all their homes and holdings sold at fire sale actions, their wives and children thrown homeless and penniless into the street, all their licenses revoked and sent to prison for life. When and if they ever get out they must wear a dead albatross around their necks and and shirts festooned with scarlet letters. Perhaps some of the recovered money could alleviate some pain coupled with a forced cramdown of mortgages.
Maybe I’m just a little harsh, but I don’t think so. And never mistake me for being on the side of hedge funds.
HolderGate or is it MERSGate or is it Obama Housing Fraud Gate. What the banksters did was not illegal. The Dept of InJustice says so. That is the same as Tony Soprano’s consigliere, Silvio (Steven Van Zandt) advising Tony Soprano to be a hedge fund manager. Then he could really steal big time.
Obama’s reckless amorality has caught up with him, and he has his own crooked, but inept, crime family.
I see no sign whatsoever of conflict – they are out to screw the 99% and defend the TBTF banks at all cost.
I’ll carry the other end of that banner.
I am with you.
Is there some kind of statute of limitations that is in play here?
Could be one reason the stretch out negotiations out…
Love your work…
Can I hold up the middle?
~
mic check! Dems who arrange amnesty for criminal bankers should arrange a private sector job for themselves next term !!
Take the crumbs from the table that our betters are offering us, cause if we don’t we might not get anything? Do I translate correctly? Also, of course make sure that those who knowingly stole the money from a generation are maintained in their positions of power.
Absolutely.
~
the only way to have free speech is to own a printing press -
kudos for finding a medium that Clear Channel hasnt decided to make $s off of yet!
keep up the agitating & keep up the educating –
‘art is agitation’ g.singlaub
~
& also – that commenter simply ignored the the obvious conflicts ingrained in the Obama DOJ on this matter, which was the meat of this post
…suggesting that ‘we better take all that our masters are gonna give us with a great big smile’ when the architects of the so-called ‘act of law enforcement’ (cause that’s what the ‘get bankers off scott free settlement’ is, allegedly, an act of law enforcement) are the same amoral asswipes who actually framed the legal justification for MERS?!?!
hey papau, do you also respond to the moniker ‘shaun donovan’? … ‘tom miller’?
I think it is time for Holder to resign. He failed to even investigate anyone involved in torture or civil rights violations from the previous administration. Now he can not find anyone to prosecute in the banking/brokerage/Insurance scandal that caused the economy to collapse. For his final malfeasance he is pushing for a weak settlement that has a low balled settlement payout and fine, no admission of wrong doing, no criminal charges, no further investigation into practices. He has been much harder on Medicinal Marijuana shops. He is the weakest AG the US has ever had, including Kleindienst.
Good God! Am I with you!
On the contrary, I think he is quite strong. He is personally giving cover for millions of individual criminal acts of fraud! He is a one man walking Bankster Hero!
You have got it exactly right. The biggest single reason why we have so many so complicit in such massive crimes and betrayals of the public trust is very simple: We have completely turned away from the concepts of deterrence and retribution. I am a major believer in BOTH deterrence and retribution. You’ve got to punish these cocksuckers so severely that all the other would-be cocksuckers see it, are afraid of it, and are motivated to actually think about doing something productive and non-criminal with their time and energy. Crimes of this magnitude are life-destroyers for the victims. The shameless and soulless perpetrators deserve to lose everything. In fact, they deserve to be dead.
“I want convictions–massive, numerous and totally ruinous convictions of these criminals. I want all their wealth confiscated, all their homes and holdings sold at fire sale auctions…”
I could not agree more!
Ok, let see if I got this right. The fig leaf is to cover our butts, better make it two, one for the front, because the low middle income will be stripped of everything and get the shaft in the end. The ones in the high income bracket will come out smelling like a rose?
My MAN!
(And not too harsh at all. Just right in fact.)
We understand, but many of us here do miss your voice. You were usually good for a smart quip or bon mot. I remember once when you wrote, “I hopey they don’t changey their little minds”.
Holder is Obama’s man at Justice and doing what Obama wants done. Nothing more, nothing less.
And, yes, the 1% are protected by those holding on by their fingernails to the upper 10 to 5%, and trying to work their way up to that lower 1%.
That’s Obama and his crowd, except for those already in the 1 and 0.01%.
Well It’s the same old fucking story
With your two different sets of rules
The same old fucking story
One for me, two for you
It’s the same old fucking story
It’s the same old fucking story all around yeah