Protesters have gathered outside a meeting taking place in Chicago today between officials with the Obama Administration and some state Attorneys General or members of their staff, aimed at reaching agreement on a low-ball settlement with leading banks over foreclosure fraud. The proposed settlement would give homeowners a pittance in exchange for a broad release of liability from prosecution for the banks.
About eighty members of various community and faith groups in Illinois, including national groups like MoveOn.org, National People’s Action and The New Bottom Line, have gathered outside the Chicago O’Hare Hilton Hotel. They are holding a press conference there and protesting the proposed settlement. Later in the day, the protesters plan to visit the local offices of Illinois AG Lisa Madigan, who is on the executive committee which negotiated the settlement, and the Obama for America 2012 campaign headquarters.
The protesters object to the low dollar value of the settlement, estimated at $20-$25 billion, when there is currently $700 billion worth of negative equity – money owed on mortgages less than the value of the home – in America. They also object to the fact that there has been no meaningful investigation into the depths of foreclosure fraud by the Department of Justice or any federal regulator. Further, they oppose a broad release of civil and/or criminal liability for the banks for their conduct at all levels of the housing market.
The proposed deal will get circulated to the banks today. Many of the holdout AG offices did not send a representative to the Chicago meeting. But they have the information on the settlement, and for a variety of reasons the events of the next 24 hours are seen as consequential. There are even rumors, according to Rep. Brad Miller (D-NC), of an announcement on the settlement appearing in tomorrow’s State of the Union Address. “They have not said anything to us on the State of the Union, but there’s a sense that they may do something,” added Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH), an opponent of the settlement on a conference call today.
Miller ticked off a number of unknowns surrounding the settlement. “What investigation has there actually been? What claims are being released?” Miller Asked. “Where did this $20 billion number come from for damages? What mortgages does this apply to? Does it apply to securitized mortgages that the banks don’t really own? Will they be able to pass on the losses for their own misconduct? Which homeowners get relief? If it’s just a dollar figure that the banks have to hit, will they pick the most expensive houses for relief and increase resentment against those who get the breaks in America?”
Brown, Miller and the coalition arguing for a “fair settlement” want a thorough investigation, with the inclusion of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (at this point not a part of this settlement). “It’s hard to know what a meaningful settlement would look like when we don’t have full disclosure,” Brown said. “Instead of a thorough investigation and criminal prosecutions, we’re talking about not much more than a slap on the wrist. The banks are not just too big to fail, they’re too big to jail.”
Justin Ruben of MoveOn.org, a key coalition partner, cited new polling showing that found that 70% of Americans believe the banks have not been investigated enough on their foreclosure practices, and that 60% of those polls would be less likely to support the President for re-election if he gave the banks a sweetheart deal. By contrast, the President would gain support if he announced a real investigation into Wall Street’s practices. MoveOn has forwarded a petition asking for an investigation, and has acquired over 360,000 signatures.




17 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
“About 750,000 Americans – about half of the households who might be eligible for assistance under the deal – will likely receive checks for about $1,800″ from Dday’s link above.
$1,800? That is it? That is less than one mortgage payment for most people. That is less than half people’s property taxes! That is it? Jamie Dimon personally took home billions, ruined millions of people’s lives. They get $1,800, and he is free to chide Obama for not cutting this deal sooner?
I did my part in circulating the news of the protest over the weekend, but due to health issues was not able to join them. Also from the linked article (emphasis mine):
“The settlement would only apply to privately held mortgages issued between 2008 and 2011, not those held by government-controlled Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Fannie and Freddie own about half of all U.S. mortgages, roughly about 31 million U.S. home loans.”
So about half of all homeowners are not included in this pitiful air kiss to the banks. It’s not even a slap on the wrist since they would not pay for it; and it’s nowhere near the level it needs to be or offers substantial restitution and help for the homeowners who desperately need it!
I send an email to Kamala Harris at California. I wonder how many calls/email the CA AG has gotten and how many support the banksters get out of jail proposal.
This is in a grander scale just what happened as result of the Savings and Loan crisis. At least then Milken and Keating were made scapegoats. This time Mozillo et al go free and we pay again.
The Sixty Minutes piece of several weeks back made the insightful statement that the prosecution for economic crimes has been at its lowest point in twenty years!
And the same show demonstrated that whistle blowers existed who were able to give the SEC all the more reason and all the more proof as to just which banking executives were guilty of systemic fraud on the American People. But the SEC head still insists – We can do nothing as we need absolute proof! (Which would be what? God coming down in a cloud of brimstone and thunder, saying I myself saw the fraudulent behavior.”)
By summer of 2010, only two mid level executives had been charged with anything. And never anyone at the top, even though there are emails, there are recorded phone calls of how the mortgage and financial people knew the sub prime mortgage activities were nothing but a manufactured bubble. There are also the executive signed statements from underwriters, that the sub prime mortgages were all A-okay, when the private correspondence and internal audits were leading executives to sell off their shares of those companies.
Remember HAMP?
That $1800, how many hoops, forms, affidavits, months of time to go through before anyone gets that?
And would it be taxable?
This smells.
A $20 bil settlement is not even a slap on the wrists. It’s more a ‘dap’ of the fists between partners in crime.
This is all kabuki. The deal has clearly been made. Banksters get the gold (and a Get-Out-Of-Jail-Free card) while Americans get the shaft.
It would be truly amazing to see this pitifully weak deal go through in the wake of the disclosures about why Holder and the DOJ have been so unwilling to investigate this fetid swamp of criminality on the federal level. For those not up on the news, check the Dayen and Cynthia Kouril posts from the end of last week about the astounding conflicts of interest at the DOJ, especially Cynthia’s.
Let’s see. Approximately 11 million homeowners are underwater, with approximately $700 billion in negative equity (i.e, the total amount of money that homes are “underwater”) — a loss of equity caused by the casino-like, speculative Wall Street financial feeding frenzy.
$700 billion/11 million homeowners means that the average homeowner is underwater to the tune of approximately $64,000. Now how much of a reduction in the principal of their mortgages is the average homeowner going to receive out of this so-called “settlement” of between $25-$50 billion?
With approximately $1,800/person going to pay for fees, etc. caused by “robo-signers,” I believe.
Good for the protests, but sadly, they will do no good. I do agree with getting boots on the ground, however, to protest this criminal rip off by the 1%, who get off scott-free anymore.
Our country is bought & sold, and citizens are complacent, compliant and completely willing to permit this criminal activity to go on.
“The banks are not just too big to fail, they’re too big to jail.”
Banks are ‘persons.’
Throw them in jail.
Obama will spin and mislead and try to bamboozle voters into believing this is a “Good Thing.”
Such a disappointing president.
http://my.firedoglake.com/cindykouril/2012/01/20/holder-breuer-mers-bombshell/
This is the link to the Cynthia Kouril article, please read it, and be sitting down when you do. Keep in mind when you do that MERS facilitated the creation of the MBS industry, which spawned the credit default swap monstrousities, and ultimately took us here, where nobody can prove who owns what.
I heard on the CBS Evening News a short while ago that a “settlement has been reached.”
Why should anyone believe in laws? Apparently, we can all do whatever the hell we please and there are no real consequences…
I just wonder when someone is going to do something that incites major violence (I am not advocating that, but someone is going to go over the edge).
“Apparently, we can all do whatever the hell we please and there are no real consequences…”
No, only those who can make mega-buck political contributions to those holding office can do whatever the hell they please. The rest of us can be accused of being “suspected terrorists” and summarily executed if we make trouble for the 1% or the politicians they own.