Just to recap the last 24 hours in the rule of law: if you order the massacre a village of Iraqis, you will get your charges reduced to “dereliction of duty” and get sentenced to no more than three months confinement. Furthermore, the rest of your colleagues that participated in the incident will not serve any jail time. By contrast, if you blow the whistle on the torture of a terrorist suspect, you will go to jail, at least if the government has its way.
The Justice Department on Monday charged a former Central Intelligence Agency officer with disclosing classified information to journalists about the capture and brutal interrogation of a suspected member of Al Qaeda, Abu Zubaydah — adding another chapter to the Obama administration’s crackdown on leaks.
In a criminal complaint filed on Monday, the Federal Bureau of Investigation accused John Kiriakou, the former C.I.A. officer, of disclosing the identity of a C.I.A. analyst who worked on a 2002 operation that located and interrogated Abu Zubaydah. The journalists included a New York Times reporter, the complaint alleged.
“Safeguarding classified information, including the identities of C.I.A. officers involved in sensitive operations, is critical to keeping our intelligence officers safe and protecting our national security,” said Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr., in a statement.
Kiriakou is not exactly a sympathetic figure to those who will invariably end up defending him. He described waterboarding as torture but necessary in a 2007 interview to ABC News, and he actually lied about the extent of the use of the technique in the interview.
But there’s a larger point here. The Administration has reserved some of its most punitive uses of their prosecutorial discretion for government leakers and whistleblowers. Government information gets leaked all the time, of course, often by official sources doing so on behalf of the Administration for political reasons. But no Administration has prosecuted as many government officials for leaking as this one; in fact, the six criminal cases are more than all other Presidents combined. It has unquestionably had a chilling effect on other whistleblowers. The case against former NSA official Thomas Drake, which thankfully collapsed last year, is the most celebrated of these cases. But the inadequacy of that case has not stopped the Justice Department from continuing to wage war on leakers.
Frequently, the government over-classifies its secrets, shields information that the public has a right to know, and fetishizes classification of information, often to protect their own legal exposure. Whistleblowing is a time-honored tradition, and a necessary component of putting checks and balances on government power. The fact that this crackdown is happening at all damages the rule of law; the fact that it’s happening in an Administration that promised record transparency makes it even worse.




18 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
The long run of history, as you imply, is not required in the electronic age to take the measure of a man. Obama and Holder et al are known entities, sociopathic scoundrels!!!!
So … looking forward not backward only applies to the actual criminals. I see.
It would seem that certain members of the Department of Justice are skating on very thin ice at the moment. Might the persecution of whistleblowers at this juncture be construed as final acts of desperation?
Remember, Señor Adolf oversaw executions of his confederates in the bunker as the Russians were approaching the outskirts of Berlin.
Well, then, certainly Eric Holder is hot on the case of Dick Cheney and his co-conspirators who leaked the identity of CIA operative Valerie Plame who was working counter-proliferation in Iran.
Right, Mr. President?
Greenwald has as article on the same today, and Marcy has been all over this.
Or, maybe we can hear from Kiriakou about his involvement in the investigation into Wilson’s trip to Niger.
Why not go for the jugular and spill everything he knows about Cheney’s involvement in 9/11?
But no Administration has prosecuted as many government officials for leaking as this one
To that, I would add that no Administration has simultaneously allowed as much fraudulent financial activity to go unpunished.
Let’s see…3 months in jail for ordering the massacre of a village of brown-skinned Third Worlders…so maybe if you wipe out a whole country (especially one with oil, which we really really really need), then maybe you can serve under a year and it’s just a misdemeanor! Gosh…doesn’t seem right, somehow…but it’s oil, goddamn it, it’s oil!
Well, the Corporate Intelligence agency must be protected at all costs, and I do mean all costs.
National security does not include the 99%! What were you thinking!
Kiriakou didn’t blow the whistle on waterboarding when he appeared on ABC News in 2007 as a cheerleader for the efficacy of the technique.
The New York Times had been reporting on U.S. use of waterboarding since 2004.
I saw your caveat that Kiriakou isn’t a sympathetic figure, but no sale. Progressives have no business making a hero out of this douchebag. Kiriakou has been polluting the national discourse too fucking long and deserves whatever punishment he gets.
The Injustice Department works for Obama and Obama for the 1%. It’s not complicated.
When you have a killing machine to expand and protect the empire, you must protect the killers at all times. You may have to throw the occasional sop to the public if the killing are as egregious as Haditha, but “investigating” and, perhaps, a slap on the wrist of the worst offender should shut up the people. After all, the military in Iraq are protecting us from immanent invasion by that military machine.
Whistleblowers, OTOH, throw back the curtain and expose the machinations of the empire. This cannot be tolerated, so there is a concerted effort to crush this. See the treatment of Bradley Manning. I don’t think that I have to provide links here.
The Spy Masters tell us secrets are classified as “classified” because they endanger lives if revealed. But the One Percent controls the Police State and the secrets are classifed to get more wars. Everything is secret. And if something is not secret, it is made retroactively secret.
The abuse of “classification” applies to everything, wars, false flag ops by the “intelligence community”. torture, bank fraud, mortgage fraud, Oil Spills in the Gulf of Mexico, Fukushima reactor meltdowns.
The CIA gave nuclear weapons plans to Iran, as a pretext for war. This is multiple crimes, nuclear proliferation. There was no reason for this reckless provocation, other than create another war.
Thomas Drake claims that “classifed” is used to cover up US Government involvement in the 9-11 attacks.
Kiriakou was part of the Gulag and torture. So we should not be surprised that jailers of the Gulag also get imprisoned in the Gulag. But if Kiriakou reveals crimes, then he should get legal immunity.
Not to derail the thread but its no surprise. Eric Holder is a gate keeper.
In 1981, as a federal Prosecutor, he derailed an big FBI investigation into the Cosa Nostra Bufalino crime family called RABFAM. He need the testimony of an informant to pursue a case of jury-tampering involving James David Osticco, who bribed a jury member’s husband in a case against DeNaples., a mob connected billionaire who donates a lot of money to both parties.
Eric caught a little fish. :)
The Bufalino file: A look inside the FBI paper trail on NEPA’s most notorious mobster
“In his time, Russell A. Bufalino was feted by politicians, feared by his fellow mobsters and dogged by federal prosecutors.
In 2006 federal probes would lead to the arrest of Bufalino’s #2 William D’Elia, and the arrests of two judges in the “kids for cash” racket who took $2.8 million in kickbacks for putting kids in private jails.
“The kids-for-cash case is just one of more than 30 federal prosecutions of government officials and contractors that have exposed a culture of corruption in Luzerne and Lackawanna counties over the past three years.” including Senator Raphael_Musto (D)
The big fish that Holder ignored was DeNaples, who tried to open Mount Airy Casino Resort but got busted for a teeny lie on his application. He was forced to transfer the casino to his daughter for lying on his application.
Sal Cognetti Jr., the former assistant U.S. attorney who prosecuted DeNaples, acted as a character witness on his slots application.
Did you know that Casino operators get to choose their own monitors?
There are tons of connections with politicians.. Dems rush to hype Marino-DeNaples link
This may be curmudgeonly. The Rule of Law doesn’t work that way.
Even the Devil, assuming there to be one, deserves due process and unbiased prosecution. Otherwise, when you look like the Devil to someone else, where will you be?
Here. Let Eric spit in your eye and tell you it’s rain drops from heaven.
Well, certainly the recommendation from Albert Murray Jr. should have calmed some nerves.
Prosecutor in Hutton Case Defends Actions December 07, 1985|
Never the ones at the top…
Anyone know where we can find an American Robespierre?
He had no problems putting the exalted on trial.