Chart compiled by Paul Krugman showing decline in public investment by state and local governments since the 2008-2009 recession.
Austerity is a major issue abroad, particularly Europe, but it has more to do with the sclerotic economic pace in the US than most people realize. Republicans successfully got spending caps that will ratchet down the budget in years to come, and they’ve already effectively frozen it. But as Jared Bernstein and Krugman show, the bigger contribution to austerity comes from state and local budgets.
You can see the job loss track perfectly with the reduction in spending, and that probably understates it, because state and local governments contract out work to the private sector, which then gets deprived of those jobs when cutbacks occur. And, the cuts happen to be in the worst possible areas, namely investment:
That is, we’re sacrificing the future as well as the present. Oh, and the cuts that aren’t falling on investment in physical capital are largely falling on human capital, that is, education.
It’s hard to overstate just how wrong all this is. We have a situation in which resources are sitting idle looking for uses — massive unemployment of workers, especially construction workers, capital so bereft of good investment opportunities that it’s available to the federal government at negative real interest rates. Never mind multipliers and all that (although they exist too); this is a time when government investment should be pushed very hard. Instead, it’s being slashed.
I’ll just allow one example that isn’t quite a state and local cutback and won’t commonly get associated with investment, but which has been extremely devastating to the population that usually avails themselves of the services. I’m talking about legal services.
Civil legal aid groups that receive money from the Legal Services Corp. estimated that they will cut 163 lawyers and 230 other employees this year after Congress trimmed the agency’s budget by 14% for fiscal 2012, according to an LSC survey released Thursday.
The projected reductions among 132 of the 135 LSC-funded organizations follow a loss in 2011 of 833 positions. The groups in 2010 had 9,059 employees, including 4,351 lawyers. In 2012, the organizations expect to have 7,833 workers, including 3,769 attorneys.
“I was not surprised to see this,” LSC President James Sandman said, adding that the staff losses will harm the ability of civil legal aid groups to help the poor.
You’re talking about groups that just cannot afford legal aid, and therefore rely on these government provided sources for their protection from harm. But those resources are getting taken off the playing field.
All of a sudden, we’ve seen this shift of emphasis, away from the deficit and toward jobs and inequality. Even Washington Post op-ed scribbler had to admit defeat on this recently. But even if Hiatt laments about how his pet issue isn’t up in lights on the marquee anywhere, he isn’t seeing the fact that he won. He won back at the 2010 State of the Union, when Barack Obama proudly took up the cause. And look what Fred Hiatt has won! With the austerity supports in the economy, fiscal policy is subtracting from economic growth at a time when little alternative growth is getting generated, and no catch-up growth to deal with the aftermath of the Great Recession.
Austerity is a big part of that story. And austerity just doesn’t work.





42 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
But it does. It continues the aggregation of wealth for the 1%.
There, fixed it.
This is not about the gov’t not implementing policies for an economic recovery, hell a chimp could figure out how to get that done. They don’t WANT a recovery, they want nothing less than a total realignment of the wage/labor force structure and are willing to sacrifice millions and millions of Americans to get it. Debt slaves stunned by economic Shock and Awe policies obviously intended to gut working Americans into submission.
If you can’t see the train headed down the tracks, you’d better wake up quick.
Nice edit.
What they don’t get, because of their shark mentality that won’t allow them to pause in their parasiting to see what they’re doing to their own financial ecosystem, is that they’re killing their own future.
Killing people at home so we can continue to kill them abroad.
“You’re talking about groups that just cannot afford legal aid, and therefore rely on these government provided sources for their protection from harm. But those resources are getting taken off the playing field.”
Why would the government that is oppressing you provide legal aid for you?
If OWS lives it will mature into a shadow government. It will be the mechanism by which the people take collective action on their own behalf. Think Hezbolah, hopefully without the military wing.
Please continue to support Occupy Supply. Help our freedom fighters through their first winter in the field.
Perhaps OT … perhaps not.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/27/elizabeth-warren-wealth-income_n_1237607.html?ref=politics.
I guess 8 million is not too far into the 1% …
At least 50% of those who comment here have portfolios in that range, right?
25%?
10%?
5%?
Come on, it’s gotta be more than 1% who comment here?
I apologize if the Warren Report makes people take another good, long look at Elizabeth Warren … she is on “our” side … right?
In truth, I gain no pleasure from learning that Elizabeth Warren believes that fighting terrorism is “job one”, that under no circumstance will she consider the legalization of marijuana for medical purposes, or that she has a personal worth in the signicant millions. However, the claim that we should, “Just give her a chance”, needs to be counterbalanced by actual, you know, facts. Facts which, just possibly, might have some some wee bearing on what she will do if elected to office.
DW
The problem is they figure they will be dead by then, screw the kids screw the grandkids and all other life forms.
They got their’s, to hell with everyone else.
They figure they’ll kill everyone off first, so from that warped perspective, they win.
Austerity can be profitable. The Government supported hedge fund known as Freddie Mac is betting against the American people again. The newest gimmick is “inverse floaters”, and no one really knows whose money Freddie Mac is using for their toxic inverse floaters.
Recall, working for Freddie Mac is a lucrative reward for Establishment villains such as Newt Gingrich or Rahm Emmanuel. But Rahm apparently is betting against Freddie Mac.
If Warren were running as an I instead of a D then I could trust her.
In the US, austerity continues as a nagging problem in so much as the populace refuses to accept a future of serfdom grovelling at the feet of a group of self-imposed oligarchs who want to impose the hereditary right to pass control of this country on to their children.
Enough said. Elizabeth Warren is on the permanent shit list.
On edit. Just what we need.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/25/business/25warren.html?hp
Democrats do what polls well now, instead of doing what will poll well two years from now at the next election. So they do counterproductive things, or do the right things half-to-quarter assedly. Republicans are already pointing out that “massive government spending” – which is what they would have called any stimulus, large or small – is a failure. The policy precedes the message, not vice versa.
This explains it. Just what we need. Lectures from John Wesley.
And that, BSbafflesbrains, is the initial “sticking” point.
How independent will Elizabeth Warren’s political decisions REALLY be, when she has adopted ALL of the D “talking points” and allowed the D’s to advise and manage her campaign?
Suspending reason on the basis of mere “hope” is hardly the stuff of responsible citizenship … which STILL matters, even if the government of this nation is both corrupt and, in actuality, no longer legitimate.
“… governments are instituted among men (and women), deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed … whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute a new government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and happiness.”
The above quote is from “a worthless piece of paper”, so its meaning devolves to whatever the people may choose to make of it.
DW
and today in Belgium there is a General Strike protesting that country’s austerity measures. In the U.S. the populace remains largely compliant and passive (with the exception of the Occupy movement) and that’s just the way the corporate media and the ruling elites want to keep it.
Sincerity, if you can fake that you will go far in the D party. Once burned (Obama) twice shy (Any progressive sounding D)
Someone on livestream at Occupy D.C. just called this an Economic Civil Rights Movement. That is it in a nutshell. Why don’t we have rights to how money is created, distributed, and regulatedOWS IS our only HOPE.
P.S. where are the progressive Democrats carrying the water of OWS..? Nowhere. Where is Al Gore? the Antarctic
Now BSbb, that is cold.
Well, not as cold as it used to be, Gore blimey!!!
;~DW
Are you sure you want me, to be able to tell you, how much money you can make and where you can spend it? Whatever you have, I’m sure I can find some soul more deserving of your money than you are.
You might want to rethink your position.
Agreed! There was a post on Democratic Unity back in 2006 outlining how the |Dem party could save itself by doing just that sort of thing — link is http://www.democrats.com/node/7656
I had hoped that the elect Obama organization might morph into something like this, but boy howdy, did that get dismantled toot sweet! As if it had never been, and as if there would be no need for it ever again, as in re-election. But I digress.
Occupy is doing it now, you are totally right, we need to support them every way possible and especially by getting involved in the General Assemblies and taking Occupy to our own neighborhoods. The game-changing genius of Occupy is in the consensus decision-making. You don`t have to get arrested to learn enough about consensus decision-making to bring it home.
You might want to consider that the populace here thinks less Govt is a good thing.
The 1% is destroying their own financial eco-culture? You mean Americans?
Not at all, America is a pain to do business in. The rest of the world will do just fine.
Thanks HF. I was a student of consensus back in the 90′s. The downside is it’s cumbersome. The up side is the dramatic increase in the QUALITY of decisions.
You’re an idiot but then recent scientific research provides the evidence for why.
http://frogenyozurt.com/2010/03/scientific-study-conservatives-have-lower-iq/
bty
The philosophy 101 class that I attended had about 20 or so students. Class time was devoted mostly to discussion led by our instructor. About midway through the semester the half dozen of us that did most of the talking were privately instructed to remain silent. It was very awkward for awhile but soon enough others stepped forward to contribute. It was a great lesson for all of us and resulted in much improved discussion.
They are killing that future because their Gruppengeist has long recognized that capitalism is dead. Krugman is full of shite, playing grand moralizer and whatall. He is well suited to that gig.
Oh, and to preempt any nonsense about needing true, free-market capitalism, Capitalism killed itself.
So forget that Krugman inspired propaganda that they know not what they do. They have a much more awareness about what they do than you give them credit for.
The austerity budget is a worldwide theft, I have no idea what planet shooter242 lives on but it sounds a pretty grim one.
We need to tell all the pols to take their austerity budget and shove it.
I think it would be smart to connect the austerity budgets decimating our towns, states, and the land with the credit crunch/indentured labor. Both benefit the 1%. Perhaps we could get national campaign to declare a one-payment moratorium (or more) on cc, student loan, and mortgage debt. WTF if our credit ratings are already nosediving? Haven’t you all imagined getting a one payment free month because you are all such responsible people? (really this is snark-free statement.)
DING!
Both you and Phoenix Woman get the trophy.
If they really believed in the bullshit they spill about free market capitalism, they would never depend on the government for subsidies, grants, or bail outs. Why isn’t anyone talking about our Nationalized banking system? Did the US taxpayer just get a kick in the face on all fronts of the subject?
He’s not an idiot, he’s an a**hole. Conservatism is even more strongly correlated to that. Geez, why can’t I find any studies?
That planet would be the Keyboard Kamakazi. Yes, you are correct and we have to get the message to Washington and their bribers that:
WE
DO NOT
CONSENT!
There are brain dysfunction studies on Right wingers, but I haven’t seen the asshole ones yet.
The character in question lives on planet Bullshite.
You know, Zionists have been pushing their existential crisis for some time now. Shamefully, there truly is one, but of a much broader extent. That crisis is the key to the “1%”‘s project and all incremental proposals will be crushed.
You know that mountaineer who cut off his arm to save himself? That’s the metaphor for our aristocracy.
Well put
It’s a problem when the Government forces Austerity.
For individuals who practice for themselves, it works just fine.
Live within your means and even an economic downturn doesn’t hurt quite so bad.
Elizabeth Warren is a centralist, only because the conversation has shifted so far to the right, does she seem liberal. She isn’t/hasn’t sold out the left, she was never a part of it.
That would be like trusting Joe “Israel” Lieberman and Bernie “Good Talk” Sanders. Mistake.
If you haven’t concluded that shooter242 is a troll by now, you never will. Don’t feed the troll.
Obama doesn’t allow progressives to serve in any capacity within his administration.
Insults? That’s the best you can do?
http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/business/general_business/january_2012/70_prefer_free_market_to_government_managed_economy
I would suggest that the “conversation” among “the people” is progressing along quite well, of late, Surtt … the “political class” has happily been doing the $hitty “$hifting” as it benefits their Corporate Masters and them$elves, at the expense of the people, the nation, and the Rule of Law.
DW