Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell is now in full retreat mode on that bill mandating that women seeking an abortion in the state must get a trans-vaginal ultrasound (colloquially known as “state rape”) beforehand.
We saw hints of this earlier today from a spokesman. But McDonnell has now put out his own statement, asking for amendments to the bill that would modify the ultrasound from trans-vaginal to trans-abdominal:
“On Wednesday, McDonnell, who had previously said he would approve the bill, put out a statement reiterating his support for pro-life policies and informed consent laws, but essentially telling the legislature to back off.
“Over the past days I have discussed the specific language of the proposed legislation with other governors, physicians, attorneys, legislators, advocacy groups, and citizens,” McDonnell said. “It is apparent that several amendments to the proposed legislation are needed to address various medical and legal issues which have arisen. It is clear that in the majority of cases, a routine external, transabdominal ultrasound is sufficient to meet the bills stated purpose, that is, to determine gestational age.”
“Thus,” he continued, “having looked at the current proposal, I believe there is no need to direct by statute that further invasive ultrasound procedures be done. Mandating an invasive procedure in order to give informed consent is not a proper role for the state. No person should be directed to undergo an invasive procedure by the state, without their consent, as a precondition to another medical procedure.”
Recall that McDonnell previously endorsed this same bill. Somehow a “trans-vaginal ultrasound” wasn’t initially seen as an invasive procedure?
The executive director for NARAL Pro-Choice Virginia points out to TPM that this remains a mandatory ultrasound as a condition for getting an abortion, regardless of where the camera is stuck. In fact, seven other states mandate an ultrasound before an abortion: Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Kansas, Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. In Texas, the provider must then show the woman the image of the fetus before it gets aborted. In the other six states the provider must offer an opportunity to view the image. The Guttmacher Institute cites a couple reasons for this:
Since routine ultrasound is not considered medically necessary as a component of first-trimester abortion, the requirements appear to be a veiled attempt to personify the fetus and dissuade a woman from obtaining an abortion. Moreover, an ultrasound can add significantly to the cost of the procedure.
And guess who’s paying for that? The woman!
Protesters should and no doubt will continue to fight this forced medical procedure as a condition of accessing a legal medical procedure. And with McDonnell and Virginia conservatives on the run, perhaps something better will come of that protest. Might want to peek in on the other seven states, too.




28 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
In Texas, the provider must then show the woman the image of the
childfetus before it gets aborted. In the other six states the provider must offer an opportunity to view the image.Hi David, I love your reporting, but it is a fetus not a child.
This is state-sanctioned rape.
Thank you DDay. I should’ve read more thoroughly before commenting.
Wonder why VA (short for virgin) Rs didn’t mandate banana in the vagina. Seems somehow more fitting.
Maybe someone politely suggested that Bob try shoving a “trans-vaginal ultrasound” instrument up his ass. You know, just to see how it felt. Maybe Bob didn’t like that idea.
Actually, it would be “state mandated” – no choice on the woman’s part.
What would happen if the United States came apart now? There would be many attendant and consequent issues to deal with, but I’m thinking it might be the better thing in the longer term.
Which does point out how far the right has moved the terms of conversation.
McDonnell, State-Rape-Advocate, wants to be vice-preznit. If he weren’t in the running, he wouldn’t be backing down. Let us hang his support for this travesty around his neck for the rest of his life. Never forget. Never.
Sorry, liberalarts.
I was in the economic forecasting biz. It takes a lot lot lot longer for the inevitable to happen than is foreseeable in advance. (Forecasting involves not only foreseeing, but more critically, timing, which is the hard part.) Don’t know how old you are, but unless you are in your preteens, the U.S. prolly won’t fall apart in your lifetime. There’s a lot left to loot, and of 310 million peeps, perhaps only 10-20% already understand what’s going on.
Apparently these days nothing is “invasive” as far as women are concerned. Got raped & got pregnant as a consequence, maybe by incest? Hey-yo! NOT “invasive.” Make the woman gestate the fetus until birth by MANdated law, and then: hey-yo: woman & kid: yer on yer own. EFF off.
All these conservatives are all about “smaller govt” except in terms of how much they can “invade” women & girls and control their reproduction and sexualities. Then there’s no govt that’s “big enough” to dominate the women-folk.
If State-Rape-Advocate McDonnell is now “backing off,” it’s only because somehow, someone determined they’d lose money on it, rather than make money. It’s only about money.
That high, huh? You’re an eternal optimist.
I wasn’t referring to looting. I was referring to the North South divide. And I don’t know that it will ever happen. In anyone’s lifetime. Your assumptions don’t follow from my comment. GIGO.
Are there court challenges to these draconian laws? How can any court say this is ok?
Freedom to speak out against the religious right… only if you undergo rectal exam.
Freedom to Assemble… only if you stand in line and agree to be strip searched with emphasis on checking the anal cavity.
I’m beginning to think this is the new way laws will be enacted to restrict rights.
Also: other FORMER governors (of Massachusetts, I’d bet)
“On Wednesday, McDonnell, who had previously said he would approve the bill, put out a statement reiterating his support for pro-life policies and informed consent laws, but essentially telling the legislature to back off.”
————-
NOT only is he an idiotic moron, he’s a chicken too. Not willing to stand by his convictions.
I was gonna call him “somethinbg else”, but though better of it. :-)
I honestly think “We the people” can force change. So I’m not willing to give up, yet.
..
..
..
But I’m close to loading my musket and headin down to the harbor.
“Never forget. Never.”
——-
I’ve got the memory of an elephant.
I can tell you the actors that played the sons in “The Farmer’s Daughter”, starring William Windom and Inger Stevens were MIckey Sholdar and Rory O’Brien.
Wow… impressive Mr. NewCarGuy. I remember the show (and show my age by saying so), and I also remember Wm Windom & Inger Stevens… but not the names of the 2 younger actors. heh.
But I’m with you & Dearie: never forget this. I won’t, and that’s for sure (fwiw).
It’s perfectly understandable who is behind what conservative Republicans are doing to women in Virginia (and elsewhere), with Gov. Bob McDonnell (High Pastor-VA) legislating state rape of Virginia women from his right-wing bully pulpit…it’s the work of Satan.
Rick Santorum, channeling Jesus Christ and God as if Santorum’s a latter day Joseph Smith, said that all main-line Protestants are doing the work of Satan, perverting America with their Satanic policies and false-theology teachings, and Gov. Bob McDonnell (High Pastor-VA) is a main-line Protestant. Ergo, McDonnell is one of Satan’s helpers.
Hey, I’m not saying this, Rick Santorum did.
I was thinking about releasing, or pushing out, whichever works, the Southern states. As in, on their own, with or without a confederate arrangement among them. Not the United States purview, in that event. Attendant and consequent issues galore, of course, but perhaps better for the long term on the United States side. As to loading and locking, why, yes, I’ve had a thought or two in that direction.
I am feeling sick to my stomach, like i need to vomit.
I saw a picture of issa and his boys, and it looked familiar…….
INQUISITION I remember a picture in a history book of men seated behind a table draped in black, same sick smirks on their faces. Across was a woman, tied up.
They burned women, like the ones i love…burned them……..this is not a fairy tale…..
Stand up to this…
Alpha males, open your eyes, …….stand up to this…before we are 11932 germany……think of burning your loved ones alive ….this is the same thinking here….this is so sick i am pissed as hell and dissapointed in us…ahhhhhhhhhhh
i get it.
santorum,issa and the aspirin between the leg boys……got caught, as we probably all did, jerking turkeyl. someone scared the hell out of them telling them they were going to burn in eternal hell…..CATHOLIC CHURCH/INQUISITION
the only way out for them is to burn the witchy sluts that tempted them and was the cause for their boner in the first place…..
Wonder if the Republicans have been able to clone Mengele?
At the next press conference someone ought to ask the good governor’s spokesperson if McDonnell intends on doing anything for the record number of CHILDREN that are homeless in Roanoke city.
http://articles.wdbj7.com/2012-02-21/roanoke-city-schools_31084975
His “concern” for children would be more believable if he actually paid attention to the ones residing outside of the uterus for a change and in his own jurisdiction(Virginia.)
they don’t need to…i think the leftovers of the 4th reich, took all the goods and split to south america…..realized it would be better to dr evil the world through world bank, inter monetary fund, fed reserve, etc. they are now ruling greece, in fact they are ruling in the us where republicans have removed duly elected officials and replaced them with company men…….
This was the topic on Diane Rehm while the bill was being actively considered. One guest read the Federal description of rape to make the case this law was requiring a doctor to rape a woman.
Surprisingly, women called in to object to it being called rape, and then tried to defend this medically unnecessary procedure as something women should be forced to undergo to be “fully informed”.
A woman called in to explain she found it painful for her regular post cancer exam, basically calling those claiming it wasn’t invasive liars.
After that very calm and cool discussion as Diane keeps (nearly) every show, it is hard to see how anyone could support the law.
I believe what we have here is a severe case of vagina envy. Now if all the repubs will line up and put their packages into this guillotine we can grant their wishes. Bet the laws change after this procedure, and birth control is not needed.
As for Frothy, as I remember in the book he loves to quote the devil will appear in sheeps clothing. Say BAAAAA. Frothy. A quick look in the mirror will show you where Satan is.