The Senate voted to table the Blunt amendment today, but several Democrats crossed the aisle to vote with Republicans and for an amendment that would give employers effective control over the medical procedures their employees could access.
The final vote was 51-48. Sen. Roy Blunt proposed the legislation, which would let employers decide to block access to medical coverage if they had a moral objection, as an amendment to the surface transportation bill. But it overshadowed the larger bill almost entirely, the result of a campaign by Catholic bishops to stop the Obama Administration’s new birth control access rules. Ben Nelson, Joe Manchin and Bob Casey crossed the aisle and voted against tabling the bill. Olympia Snowe voted with the Democrats to table the bill, but for the most part, Republicans held firm. One member did not vote or voted “present,” I’ll have to track that down… UPDATE: Mark Kirk, who’s in the hospital recuperating from the effects of a stroke, didn’t vote.
This means that threatened incumbents like Dean Heller and Scott Brown, both of whom will likely face female challengers in November, voted to allow employers to block access to legal medical procedures, in particular women’s health care. Because of the way the vote has been structured, as a motion to table the amendment, Heller and Brown could say that they merely wanted to have the debate rather than to table the bill, but Brown, at least, has been outspoken on the amendment, on the grounds of religious freedom.
It’s been good to see, finally, some pushback from the Democrats on this religious freedom red herring. The President’s campaign weighed in on their Tumblr page with this sentiment:
“If Mitt Romney and a few Republican senators get their way, employers could be making women’s health care decisions for them.”
That’s closer to what you want to say about this. The amendment put no restriction on employers and would have allowed them to completely undermine health care for the people who work for them.
Democrats may be giddy about getting Heller and Brown to line up against women on this vote; surely Shelley Berkley and Elizabeth Warren will have a lot to say about that for the next eight months. The defections in their own ranks should cause some alarm, however. It shows that the late framing of this issue led to unnecessary vulnerabilities.
Still, the Blunt amendment is no more, and birth control, incredibly, has become a legitimate subject for debate in America. I hope America’s women are watching.




50 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I hope that All Men who love Women are also watching and raising hell that these bigots are still attacking a woman’s right to decide for the body that she lives in.. When will these asshole get it?? Would they give up their right to get Viagra?? No way in hell…
We do need men to help us stop this assault on women’s health. That’s why I ask that all of us e-mail our critters in the House and the Senate and especially the WH. If they listen to anyone, it’s men because they certainly aren’t listening to women very well. Send an e-mail every day and let them know that we’re watching.
What I don’t understand about those dumbass male legislaturds all over the country is that, in MY house, we always had a rule, “If momma ain’t happy nobody is happy.” Pissin’ off women in such huge numbers is NOT a smart thing to do.
I like your suggestion. I’ll drop some emails accordingly.
We’ve been watching alright. Watching while politicians have made hay over decisions and choices that can change a woman’s life.
Joe Manchin, Casey, and Sen. Nelson can kiss my backside as can the other “giddy” Democrats.
This isn’t an f’in “game” of political one upmanship for those of us that actually have female reproductive organs.
Thanks, ncg. Every little bit helps.
Good that people here are paying attention. But “here” is not the nation. Not enough women care about their own rights, still, just like not enough Americans in general care about issues that really affect them. These legisturds, mostly R’s, have been attacking women’s rights for decades, and yet, they’re still elected and re-elected. Why? Because too many women either don’t know what’s going on, know but don’t care, or stay home. And in the case of people who should care the most about this: younger, single women, they are one of the groups least likely to vote in elections. I keep seeing comments that elections don’t matter. Well, yeah, they do.
you assume that the elections results are not rigged. the gold standard of voting in a democracy are individually marked and counted ballets. what we have is a clown on a major network telling us who won in the middle of the night….
Please. Look at exit polls of who votes. Suburban conservative married women – who probably use birth control themselves, or can’t stand to have their husbands’ hideous corpulent bodies on them anyway – high voter participation. Single women under thirty – very low voter participation. In 2010, almost non-existent. This is no Diebold conspiracy.
I agree. Elections do count. You have to be in Congress to actually do destructive things and we need to choose the very best and push them hard.
I’m hoping that with OWS and all the other stuff that’s going on out there the younger women will change those stats this year, and in future years. Yes, elections do count. I also hope that those who stayed home in 2010 have realized that that was a mistake that we’ve all paid for in spades.
Casey another floating democratic turd in the democratic punch bowl
I have plenty of reasons not to give money to the DCCC (in spite of getting dozens of spams every week), but Bob Casey is, in and of himself, reason enough not to give.
My level of respect for a party that is willing to throw women overboard to placate two swing voters in Macomb County, Michigan (who won’t vote Democratic anyway) is absolute zero.
The way I see it, it’s about who pays the bill.
And you know what’s in the punch bowl besides the turds? Weak tea.
The devils in the details of the Blunt Instrument amendment.
How would an employer have exercised their “freedom of religion,” enforcing their religious and “moral” biases on employees under their authoritarian thumb?
Would these type of employers not only have told an insurance company to withhold coverage over anything that these type of employers found objectionable, but would these type of employers have also demanded from insurance companies medical records of present employees as well as anyone seeking a job, just for these type of employers to make sure no one “immoral” was working there or seeking employment?
IOW, what if a woman seeking employment at a company run by one of these religious kooks had had an abortion many years ago (maybe to save her life, or after being raped), but since then she’s raised a family, has several children, but runs into a Blunt Amendment-sanctioned employer who views any abortion, no matter for what reason, as being “immoral”? What if she’s used contraceptives for most of her life (as most American women have at one time or another), but still has children that need to be fed and raised, and she tries to get a job at a business (in a tight economy) run by one of these religious fanatics? How would the business owner know, unless he or she required medical records and insurance records to be submitted with any job application?
This is why I agree with so many others that the Blunt amendment was and still is an abomination. The devils in the details.
we also have planes fall from the sky
Agreed. But hope is not a plan. The previous post about low Democratic enthusiasm – understandable but disturbing – is not a good sign. Low enthusiasm, really? No enthusiasm for at LEAST voting for the lesser of two evils, which in many cases is much, much less evil and won’t create a theocracy? Sad.
Lesser of two evils? Good Lord I am sick to death of having people preach at me about how Democrats are necessarily the “lesser of two evils.”
Particularly when in the case of Casey, Manchin, and Nelson they are NOT.
Nelson is leaving. If I were a female Democratic voter in Pennsylvania or West Virginia I’d be writing someone in before I voted for either of these choices. Lesser evil my backside.
If they don’t like paying for health care options for their employees then they can drop coverage in entirety and that would allow their employees to enter the governmental pool. You don’t get to discriminate against a half of the species though and call it “your” religious freedom.
I’ll never have a prostate exam or need to worry about testicular cancer but you don’t hear me whining about having to pay for their coverage. Furthermore, using God as an argument is ridiculous. Using the logic that is invoked I should be able to argue against ANY medical coverage. I can argue I don’t want someone to have chemotherapy because God apparently wanted them to have cancer since He gave it to them to begin with.
the difference between exit polls and the actual results have grown over the last 2 decades. the US and the UN monitor this difference in elections all over the world to ID election fraud. When there are growing discrepencies in the US our media comes up with all kinds of BS excuses even though our computerized election tabulations are hackable more ways than i can count. the US has brought home techniques used and perfected by the cia and others since ww2. When the left was winning in Mexican presidential election a few years ago votes started to come in for conservative victor at a rate of upwards to 200 to 1(the votes are time stamped in mexico). Political Science statasticians will tell you that is exstremely unlikely without fraud. Karl Roves computer guy was being depositioned regarding the 04 ohio presidential results which were altered thru a man on the middle atttack. Conveniently the computer guy, Michael Conner i believe,his plane went down and crashed killing him before the deposition was completed. Funny how that happens……
Who voted the right way on this bill? That’s right, ALL Dems, plus one R who announced her retirement. So two Dems vote with the enemy, therefore a pox on all Dem houses? Really? Enjoy sitting out the next election then, and see the results you get. Hope you’re not a woman. Or gay, or black, or a member of the 99%.
I don’t know if you are aware of this but there hasn’t been a single piece of anti woman legislation that has passed without the assistance of Democrats.
Partial birth- Democrats involved The friggin conscience clause debate during the health care debacle-introduced by a douchebag male Democrat ….
In my state the Democrat running for Webb’s Senate seat is an anti choice Democrat just like his opponent. So essentially if you believe in a woman’s right to choose in Virginia you are screwed this cycle.
Not ALL Democrats. Three friggin morons crossed the aisle just like one Republican crossed the aisle.
The problem with people like you is you just don’t get it. This isn’t a football game. Get over the jersey color and educate yourself on where politicians actually stand on issues. Quit running around acting like all Democratic choices are equal, they aren’t.
Conspiracy! Conspiracy! Yeah, that’s the ticket.
Back to my original point. Women are 51 percent of the population. Contraception is very popular, even among some conservative women, and definitely among men who love women. There is no reason why there should be so many elected politicians waging a vagihad, unless they were pretty sure they could get away with it.
I agree with you.
Let the employers drop insurance for everyone. Except I don’t think ObamaCare allows that.
Then primary them. Vote them out. Work to elect pro-choice Dems. Or, don’t. Curse politics and shake your fist at the sky while you’re being vaginally probed.
It allows them to drop coverage and pay a fee if I am not mistaken, just like it does for individuals.
Shake your pom poms.
After their done decimating women’s choice, you’re constituency may be next on the list of folks the Democrats are willing to sell out or exploit to win elections. Keep thinking it’s only women that have to worry about being probed bub.
That seems fair.
Employees can buy their own insurance, or not if they pay a fee, and the “religious” employeer can still have a clear conscience and probably save money in the long run.
Conspiracies never happen right? The Nazis set fire to their Reichstag in the early 30′s. How many years did it take for the German people to realize the truth? Character asassinating someone as a tin foil hat wearing fool has always been one of the tactics of those not wanting their bad deeds to come to light. Given the power and $$$ at stake we are more similar to ancient,corrupt Rome then we would like to think
They? Who is THEY? Try voting or organizing people to vote for a progressive candidate.
Or…
Shake your fist at the sky and at me and pray for a pox on all their houses.
Then see which is more effective.
So the Nazis are to blame for the anti-contraception jihad in America?
No, it’s the American voters who put these creeps in office. 51 percent are women. There should be no politician of any party who would take rights away from 51 percent. In any state. Maybe except Utah. Why do they? Because they don’t fear the repercussions. They don’t fear you. Maybe because you’re spouting conspiracy nonsense.
My original point was not controversial. Elections matter. If you don’t like the results, there is always another election.
I’m from Pennsylvania and Casey just lost my vote.
They is the democratic party.
My goodness thank you ever so much for telling me that I should get politically active. That thought had never occurred to me. I mean just because I’m visiting a site that actually touts political activism doesn’t mean I’ve ever engaged in it. I just come here for the pretty pictures.
I would be utterly shocked if you weren’t a staffer from a member of the ballless and clueless sect of the Democratic party. If you aren’t you totally missed your calling. Gimme a d.
Shake that fist at the sky! I bet the sky is making you mad.
Wave your pom poms. Everytime a worthless Democrat gets a congressional seat an angel gets its wings.
C’mon C’mon gimme that D. Go Team Blue. Go Team it isn’t our fault that we don’t actually mean many of the planks in our platform and don’t insist our membership commit to them.
Well they’ll take back the vote soon too.
Don’t worry you can bet Democrats will be right there with the GOP helping…
This is not about one party….both of these political corrupt entities(Dem Party & GOP) have helped to get us where we are today…
just look at the indefinite detention that they passed a few weeks ago,yes the one where the Prez issued a signing statement ? to make it seem like he is such a good compassionate Prez…..well both Dems & GOP played their part including some of those so called better Democrats that we keep hearing to go out and elect.
Anyone remember the “Stupak Amendment”,that was done by Democrats & a Dem Prez…..they are so bent on screwing women over,they had the signing with no media….these are the people fighting for women rights.
Screw the Dems & GOP parties,start the Revolution & vote 3rd party folks.
“Conspiracy! Conspiracy! Yeah, that’s the ticket.” is a bit unfair as all you were saying was a bit of truth – indeed we now have a great deal more information and the mathematical types on the left are still doing research that refines the estimates on how and where and to what extent the electronic non-audited vote was changed. That is what makes the Bev Harris betrayal so evil (Bev is the “Blackbox” hero to some because she claims her successful efforts to get a group together to destroy the Rep Rush Holt (D-NJ) HR 811, the Voter Confidence and Increased Accessibility Act back in 2007 was just an effort to make it better – knowing of course that demanding paper only would kill the only chance we had for automatic election audits).
But your valid point is not on the original posts point – the fact we can not automatically trust Democrats on anything to the left of the GOP – especially if their name is Obama.
Someone has Democrats Tourettes(TM)
Me: Looks like it might rain.
- DEMOCRATS! DEMOCRATS make rain!
Me: Mmmmmkay, but I’m going to take an umbrella.
- Bet it’s a DEMOCRAT UMBRELLA, collaborator!
Me: Okay, bye.
Let me spell it out for you reeeeal slow. Conspiracies are merely agreements by a group to ingage in some kind of bad activity. Many times these activities are not understood to have happened for a long time, usually after it is too late to do anything about it. The Nazis did that in the 30′s. Anyone who questioned it would have been thought the fool,discredited or worse. Your response makes me think you are some combination of fool or troll polluting this site with your stubborn ignorance.
He’s got go. Find a woman to primary him.
Mr Dayen, as you re-write other people’s articles with minimal attribution, could you please include basic information like Senate Rollcall numbers?
If you could look past your fetish for attribution, the roll call info is essentially there in David’s post.
The topic was voting, and who voted for what on this bill, and how the vote was too close for comfort. You are the one who polluted the thread with your idiocy about conspiracy and Nazis and your name calling and belligerence.
I’m aware of what a conspiracy is. There is no conspiracy when something bad is done out in the open like voting for or against a bill. Either you like the way your rep voted, and you want to reward them, or you don’t, and you punish them. So stuff your Nazis.
Someone has Democratic Cheerleading Syndrome secondary to Denial
Me: Both parties are complicit in screwing over constituencies. You should not be voting based on a person’s party identification particularly when party identification no longer means a member must conform to platform ideals.
You: But but but the republicans are MORE evil. Go Team Blue! Go Fight Win! More Better Democrats yaaaay team!
You’ve been trying for “more better democrats” for over a decade. How’s that been working out for the nation?
You might not want to hear this but when the Democrats had control of the House, Senate and the WH, they made the same party that made them hold investigative hearings down in a basement when they were in minority point men on their crowning acheivement. There’s a reason for that and it ain’t because they are “lesser evil” then the other party. The two party system is bought and paid for by corporate America and if you ain’t incorporated then they could care less about your “rights.” The fact that someone has a D after their name simply means they rotate the blame to hide the backstabbing rather than the strsightforward frontstabbing that the GOP engages in.
As far as I understand the Blunt Amendment, it would allow any employer to deny coverage for any medical treatment that he/she frowned upon, and evidently without any requirement that the employer must show a genuinely held religious objection (compare to conscientious objectors).
So, seemingly, the Christian Science Church, or any individual Christian Scientist who owns a business, could cut out all medical care and drug coverage on the ground that the CS church doesn’t like it, and recommends prayer for all illnesses.
Similarly, a Jehovah’s Witness could prevent his/her employees from having coverage for blood transfusions.
And so it goes. This is what happens when you have a crappy law, like Obamacare, that continues the no-longer rational approach of having medical insurance, and thus medical care, dependent upon employment and the employer’s wishes about what gets covered and what doesn’t.
Back to the company town and company store we’re going.
This is Religious POWER not FREEDOM! Lets get the framing right.
(oops, mis-linked and deleted)
Similarish problems at the local level. WA state leg. had a D supermajority a few years ago, and a D gov. Lot’s of middle-of-the-road Ds, though, dubbed “the Road-Kill Caucus” and excoriated by the liberal weekly paper for being too scared to do any “freaky liberal shit” for fear of angering moderate voters and losing their supermajority. Of course, the supermajority is of no use if you won’t use it, and then they lost it anyway…