It’s Super Tuesday, where we will perhaps see the final coronation of Mitt Romney as the nominee of the Republican Party for President. A win for Romney in states like Ohio and Tennessee should put the race out of reach, even if it doesn’t immediately lead to the other candidates dropping out.
And I would argue that the rise of Romney coincides directly with his turn to a very negative, even cruel side of his personality, and how it’s reflected in his public policy choices. Romney hoped to float above the GOP primary, winning on the strength of outside negative ads, superior fundraising and better organization. That didn’t totally work out. So he had to alter his economic policy, to tilt it further to the right, to embrace more conservative ideas. He had to become the most conservative candidate on immigration policy. And he had to do things like he did in Youngstown, Ohio yesterday, a perfect example of the conservative “you’re on your own” economic profile:
The high school senior who stood up at Mitt Romney’s town hall meeting here today was worried about how he and his family would pay for college, and wanted to hear what the candidate would do about rising college costs if elected. He didn’t realize that Mr. Romney was about to use him to demonstrate his fiscal conservatism to the crowd.
The answer: nothing.
Mr. Romney was perfectly polite to the student. He didn’t talk about the dangers of liberal indoctrination on college campuses, as Rick Santorum might have. But his warning was clear: shop around and get a good price, because you’re on your own.
“It would be popular for me to stand up and say I’m going to give you government money to pay for your college, but I’m not going to promise that,” he said, to sustained applause from the crowd at a high-tech metals assembly factory here. “Don’t just go to one that has the highest price. Go to one that has a little lower price where you can get a good education. And hopefully you’ll find that. And don’t expect the government to forgive the debt that you take on.”
In this answer, Romney basically denies the existence of federal student loan programs, Pell grants, work-study programs, or the soaring cost of higher education, a real crisis for the country, something that the President has actually noted and tried to tackle, through a somewhat vague idea of linking government aid to colleges and universities to slowing their growth in prices. He also denies the efficacy of a college education as an investment in the future, and how money spent by the federal government – again, in existing programs – pays off down the road. Nope, the message was, “tough noogies, shop around, good luck, go away.”
This may not appeal to a college student, but it appeals to a large sector of the GOP base that assumes that any government policy represents a handout to an undeserving alien other. That’s the lizard brain appeal of Romney’s comments, which received an ovation. Romney may not have wanted to tread on this ground, but the nature of the Republican primaries demanded it. And that has led to the tarnishing of the brand.




23 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
If you’re not smart enough to figure out how to pay for your college, you’re not smart enough to go to college.
Don’t be deceived by saying to yourself, “He’s only saying that to get elected.” Look how well thinking that helped to elect Herbert Hoover #2, Bush #3.
Mitt basically said banks need to charge students high interest rates on student loans and pocket fees and Mitt will defend their parasite behavior.
I guess Mitt doesn’t think there are enough Young Republican votes on college campuses to pander too. What Mitt said today will make the College Young Republicans about as popular on every college campus as a keg of near beer.
Well Mitt is being honest about how the 1% views the 99%. We can go get stuffed for all Mitt cares. And why not? It’s the 1% who are *paying* to run Mitt as their putative “Republican candidate.” I’ll give Mitt a half a credit for not trying to candy-coat how the 1% thinks.
Given Mitt and the entire GOP’s debate performances so far I can understand why they don’t want to help poor college students the 1% are inbred and Mitt fears his kid’s can’t compete unless the deck is stacked.
The University of Mexico is tuition free – you just have to make it through an army of border patrol and over a fence and then hope you will not be treated like undocumented students in Georgia of Florida.
One wonders about elite Ivy league schools that give diplomas to Bush and Qualye.
One wonders at colleges that teach Chicago and Austrian school economics that have lead us to economic ruin.
One wonders about schools that let professors deny Global Warming. One wonders at colleges that taught army officers who approved Bush’s war plans for Iraq and Afghanistan.
One wonders while Mitt was avoiding the army and doing missionary work if he was just converting people or actually helping poor people?
Tarnishing the brand? Really Dave? That ‘brand’ is so damned tarnished it’s mostly all rust. Anyone that thinks above the level of alligator knows this.
It’s really sad though to see half the country oblivious to the serious problems we will have competing on the world stage while other countries are quietly doubling up on educating their populations and improving infrastructure.
Americans will have fewer jobs and be transformed into a slave colony of underpaid waiters/waitresses and bartenders for BRICS tourists and Wall Street hedge fund managers! (well we are practically already there on the Wall ST. part)
Go fly a kite, troll.
I’d rather hear the truth, also.
I’ve seldom read a more depressing paragraph.
“Go to one that has a little lower price where you can get a good education. And hopefully you’ll find that”. (my bold)
You won’t find one, after a while. Few students can afford college without some governmental assistance. Fewer colleges will be able to open their doors as a result. Soon only the very fortunate and the wealthy will be able to attend college. And by the very fortunate, I mean those who not only work hard but have been spared, by some kind fate, the accident, illness, or yes, poor choice that can bring the world crashing down.
What Mitt is really saying is…. “You don’t have a right to a college education if you are not rich.” That’s the bottom line. If you can’t afford it, then you can’t have it.
agree. frankly, as I stated, at least Mitt’s being reasonably *honest,* rather than tap-dancing around and pretending that he gives a shit. Mitt does not give a shit. That’s where it’s at.
You’re on your own. Get used to it.
Might as well tell the truth.
yes, that as well. If you’re not in the upper part of the 99% or in the 1%, then forget it. And with the costs of a tertiary degree these days, citizens had better consider carefully whether it’s worth it… bc it probably isn’t unless you’re “connected.”
As someone said the other day, once the boomers die off, the middle class, as we know it, will be long gone. Sad to say… citizens might as well start figuring it out.
Got.Ours.Pissoff.
There is nothing about nature, or the planet, that is kind or gentle, or gives a damn about our survival. If we can’t expect kindness, gentleness or caring from each other what the fuck use are we, anyway?
p.s. I sent you a “friend” request a while back. Unless you are just not into the friend thing, will you be mine? :)
Over the years I’ve noted that, as the govrernment takes on the task of enabling (and I use that word in a positive context) citizens to better themselves, or better feed themselves, or better house or care for their health, then that aspect of our society grows exponentially more & more expensive for EVERYONE.
My question: is this a bug or a feature of our (or of any) economy)?
My high school daughter is taking an Advanced Placement course in Human Geography. The textbook has a ton of great maps comparing key demographic indicators in different countries. What is striking is that the U.S. has dropped far down in most indicators, for example, it only ranks 13th in the world in the composite Human Development Index (“HDI”) developed by the United Nations, and in average life expectancy and infant mortality rates is way behind Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and Western Europe. These maps convincingly show that the U.S. is on the cusp of becoming a full-fledged second tier nation, aligned more closely in its standard of living with most of Latin America and Eastern Europe than with the most advanced nations.
Being closely aligned with latin america is to be expected given the number of latin americans allowed to wander into this country.
Yo, RuntAssKick. I’m sending you a big hug, ’cause you seeem like someone who needs it.
Hell, if you’re not smart enough to be born into a wealthy family, don’t ever think about running for president either. According to Mitt’s dad, if you have to work for a living you can’t afford to run for high office.
Some MCMer (member of the Mainstream Corporate Media) said last night, on Charlie Rose iirc, that even if it takes until June Mitt will have plenty of time to change his image with the voters between then and the election.
Enough money and enough ads can remake anyone. Romney the Centrist will emerge as he gets closer to closing the deal with Repubs.
Romney plans on much much more of the “I got mine to hell with you” policies the GOP backed big business has practiced for the past thirty years. Corporations are unrelenting in the takeover of what was once the commons. Education costs continue to rise to levels now un-affordable to the majority of working and middle class households. Student debt now outranks credit card debt and if any of the GOP wannabe’s would happen to win this election you’ll be damned lucky if your kids get a primary education let alone have affordable access to higher education. Romney used accounting gimmicks and stock tricks to give his five sons $100,000,000 to split among themselves,twenty million each, yet he did this for them tax free through defered stock transfers and earnings. As he said “I wanted to give them a nice start in life”. Some start. Romney’s tax plan will have catastrophic consequences for the debt and budget. Average savings for taxpayers in the bottom 20 percent: $78. Savings for the top 0.1 percent where the Romney’s reside: $239,000. As of now, he says his tax plan can’t be scored by the CBO. That’s because he refuses to say what programs he will cut or end.
The fact that Romney received a sustained ovation by factory workers shows either their fear of retaliation by their boss, the host of the event, and/or the success of the propaganda machine at work in business today. Many business managers have a extremely rigorous applicant screening process that weeds out such undesirables as free thinkers and those with politically divergent (ie liberal) opinions. Narcissists and self interested people and those with non-criminal psychopathic tendencies are sought out for the ranks of both the front office and the factory floor.I don’t know the name of this company, it is irrelevant, but I can say with certainty this is a non-union company and one that is virulently non-union. Places like Youngstown and the town where I live, also in Ohio, used to be the heart and soul of unionization until they were made into the “American Rustbelt” by corporate chieftains who moved the jobs to slave labor countries beginning in the late seventies and continuing until the people were begging in the streets. Over the years many of these same workers fell victim to the propaganda machine, blaming the de-industrialization of the area on unions. Now, sadly, they have become the new low wage slaves of the same corporate masters.