Remember the charge of the light brigade last week after the defeat on the Blunt amendment vote? Conservative lawmakers said they would not retreat, would not rest until all women had to get permission slips from their employers to access legal medical services, and possibly before protected having sex. The fact that health care is part of the compensation package, and that this amounted to giving employers a say over what women could do with the money they earned, wasn’t relevant. Conservatives, in thrall to those who want to control your bedroom behavior, would fight on.
Flash forward to a week later and they’re not fighting on. In the Senate, Roy Blunt, author of the amendment giving employers a say over health care decisions, basically pronounced “mission accomplished” today:
“You know, I think we’ve got as many votes as I think there were to get on that,” Senate GOP Conference Vice Chairman Roy Blunt told TPM Tuesday afternoon after a weekly Capitol briefing. “I think the House side may take some further action. That debate will go on for a long time, though I don’t know that there’s anything else to happen in the Senate in the near future.” [...]
These concessions delight Democrats, who plan to revisit the events of the last several weeks, and the vote on the Blunt amendment, as the election nears.
Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY), who devised the Democrats’ legislative and messaging strategy in this fight, told TPM, “I think Republicans know that it hasn’t served them well.”
As for the bravely bold claim by Blunt that the House would take up the fight, that’s not happening either:
House Republican leaders are taking their foot off the gas, slowing down plans to pass legislation taking aim at the Obama administration’s contraception coverage requirement, according to sources close to leadership.
“I think the Senate already took action and we’ve got a lot else on our plate,” said Rep. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.), who is running for Senate.
The vehicle for this in the House, the “Respect for Rights of Conscience Act” by Rep. Jeff Fortenberry, already has 219 co-sponsors in the House. In other words, passage would be assured. But Republicans are slinking away.
It’s definitely not a time to pronounce victory on women’s rights in America. They have been successfully chipped away at the state level to such a degree over the last few years that it will take a monumental effort just to return to the status quo of, say, the year 2000. But I don’t think there’s any doubt that conservatives overplayed their hand here. The fact that Rush Limbaugh is losing advertisers far faster than he ever lost pounds is another indicator. A new, younger breed of women activists have kept the pressure on and successfully navigated a few fights on crucial women’s health issues, to the degree that the GOP doesn’t want to touch them anymore.
There was definitely damage to making contraception subject for debate. But there was also a benefit to raising awareness about the preventive services benefits in the Affordable Care Act, including birth control without a co-pay. This plants a flag on women’s health that needs to expand and not just be maintained. But with the surge of support on the issue, that path is actually possible in a way it wasn’t before. That’s especially true if the activists can make this an electoral issue going forward.




13 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Maybe the danger of being “Komened” was pointed out.
“Bravely ran Sir Robin…” I love a good Monty Python reference.
Shall we say that Rep Jeff Flake is, (paraphrasing) “…the Chicken of the Capitol, who had personally wet himself at the Battle of Contraception on the Hill!”
Can’t help but be suspicious that this whole contraception thing was a deliberately engineered smokescreen to divert public attention from the recent passage of H.R. 347 aka the Federal Restricted Buildings and Grounds Improvement Act of 2011 making most forms of public protest a felony. No democrats voted against this nasty bill that Obama’s getting ready to sign.
yes, why doesn’t someone post the youtube clip from monty python and the holy grail? we could all use a laugh.
Let’s be fair….”Discretion is the better part of valor.”
Some of us can concentrate on 2 things at once.
My personal opinion is despite their “win” on contraception that each and every person who voted against the first amendment should be primaried.
thanks for the well intended heads up….well done….sorry someone needs to be a wise ass about your words.
please join me if you will…use the logic in this article to put a stop to this bullshit quickly ( i do not know the ju ju magic to drag the words here)….towit: the american pay system often includes fringe benefits as part of earned remuneration (like sick leave, paid holidays, health care payment plan). now these fucks want to tell us how to spend our money after we sweat our asses off or break our backs to earn it.
use it to shut their pie holes fast…..
Who was a wise ass?
GOP sluts have decided to STFU.
To paraphrase Springsteen:
“No retreat, just surrender.”
Blunt-RUBIO Amendment.
I dunno, just seems awfully convenient, somehow. Manufacturing outrage is nothing new. Issa calls a stupid hearing on a non-issue, dems can’t get their witness so they do their own mini-hearing, Rush does his usual blovious infuriating rants thereby generating yet another RW shitstorm (prediction, no adverse consequnces for anyone except d’s & Ms. Fluke) meanwhile H.R. 347 passes with only Ron Paul & two other r’s voting against it. I try to stay informed yet only learned about it two days ago AFTER it had passed both houses & was ready to sign.
i reviewed your words, in particular after you throw your insult, and follow with the really important “my personal opinion is”. i thought about your “who was a wise ass”……after that deep thought only one response feels right, because the hair on the back of my neck is standing up just interacting with you in this was…so here is my well thought out answer to your query…….
fuck you …..good day