To the surprise of absolutely no one, Senate Republicans blocked consideration of the Buffett rule last night with a filibuster. The bill would have set a millionaire’s minimum effective tax rate at 30%, with a phase-in between $1 million and $2 million and an exemption for charitable donations. But Senate Republicans wouldn’t let it get onto the floor for debate.
I am pretty proud of myself that I called Susan Collins as the only Republican who would vote for the bill. Mark Pryor was the only Democrat to vote against it. Joe Lieberman passive-aggressively did not make it back to Washington for the vote, but said in a statement that he would have voted no on the bill. Daniel Akaka didn’t make it back from Hawaii, but presumably he would have been a yes. Here’s the roll call.
Yesterday on a conference call, Chuck Schumer said this would not be the end for the Buffett rule, and that Senate Democrats would pursue it all year long. And I believe him, because it has become bound up with the Presidential election. Here’s President Obama’s statement on the vote:
Tonight, Senate Republicans voted to block the Buffett Rule, choosing once again to protect tax breaks for the wealthiest few Americans at the expense of the middle class.
The Buffett Rule is common sense. At a time when we have significant deficits to close and serious investments to make to strengthen our economy, we simply cannot afford to keep spending money on tax cuts that the wealthiest Americans don’t need and didn’t ask for. But it’s also about basic fairness – it’s just plain wrong that millions of middle-class Americans pay a higher share of their income in taxes than some millionaires and billionaires. America prospers when we’re all in it together and everyone has the opportunity to succeed.
One of the fundamental challenges of our time is building an economy where everyone gets a fair shot, everyone does their fair share, and everyone plays by the same rules. And I will continue to push Congress to take steps to not only restore economic security for the middle class and those trying to reach the middle class, but also to create an economy that’s built to last.
So it’s much more than just another filibuster. It has resonance as a principle for the election. That’s especially true because of Mitt Romney benefiting from the rule, given his low tax rate (although it should be noted that Obama, who made less than $1 million last year, also paid a lower tax rate than his secretary, and still would if the Buffett rule applied to him, because most of his deductions came from charity).
The debate on taxes will continue, and with the Buffett rule polling very high, Democrats are sure to keep pushing it, drawing out the contrast with Republicans when it comes to taxes on the very rich.




23 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
O: “At a time when we have significant deficits to close and serious investments to make to strengthen our economy, we simply cannot afford to keep spending money on tax cuts that the wealthiest Americans don’t need and didn’t ask for.”
he’s talking less than $5 billion – not even enough to pay for 3 of his stealth bombers…
BREAKING NEWS: No one was more surprised by the failure of the Buffett Rule to advance in the Senate than President Obama.
The Bush tax cuts that Obama adopted as his very own were a significant part of the overall stupidity that led to the problems we had during the first decade of the 21st century.
As if this outcome wasn’t known in advance.
one and a half cheers for the Democratic Party doing something politically smart.
SHOCKED I am
The only difference b/t D’s and R’s in D.C. is D’s pretend to care and R’s have dropped the pretense. Neither care about America , the Constitutional Democracy we are supposed to be striving toward, or other people’s children.
Considering the Buffet rule is essentially in place (28% AMT) one would think that the Democrats would realize the class war card is a loser. Exhibit A is the Obama/Bush tax rates currently in place. If DC had a real discussion over what constitutes capital gains, progress might be made.
YAWN.
Yeah, it’s politically smart if you’re a 1%er. Now they’re redefining ‘middle class’ as being those who make less than $1M a year. Those making far less than $1M should be paying far more than 30%, but instead Obama and the Democrats are now saying those for instance making $800K (not coincidentally what the Obamas made) are part of the protected middle class. This is called starving the beast by saying that everyone except for an extremely small part of the population (less than 1%) should pay 30% in taxes. Saying that those 1%ers making $500K per year aren’t millionaires is ridiculous. Pretty soon Obama will have everyone that doesn’t have a corporate jet be considered “middle class” and will starve the beast both with the “middle class” and even the very limited defined rich.
This is meant to be a Dog And Pony Show. Obama doesn’t want to have to explain why his own rule wouldn’t apply to him.
Some days you’re the windshield. Some days you’re the bug.
..
..
Lots fewer windshield days under Obama than I had hoped for.
FWIW, I resigned my democratic party precinct chair position today. I just can’t work for this president or the current democratic party. I thknk my grandpa would approve.
Wow, this is hopefully a new beginning for our Country. The early stages for sure but saying goodbye to the D’s is hard and I’ll bet very hard for you since you seem like a True Truman Dem from the old days. I can’t buy in to the D’s bullshit anymore either so I am reregistered as I. Keep the faith ncg.
Good on you…..the DNC is not worthy just like the GOP.
It seems the only alternative left is militant street action….
Legal Civil Disobedience will win. Get out of the Consumer driven, corporate controlled life and just say no to credit, debt, and selfish consumption = liberty and ultimate happiness. No need to throw rocks or insults.
It is hard when you have been active. I remember leaving the Democratic party at the end of 2007. It is like leaving your church. When you have been active it goes way beyond politics. So many personal relationships are tied up in party activism. Congrats. You did the right thing.
I’m all for that. Let’s get started soon because here in Texas it gets REALLY hot in the summer. Perhaps we can have the revolution over by mid-June????
Oooooh. We COULD write another “Declaration of Idependence on July 4th. THAT way we wouldn’t have to remember another holiday. Ya’ know they’ve got like three “independence days” in Mexico.
You know I am ALWAYS with you.
But, I am kinda attached to “selfish consumption”.
Don’t worry in our new society you can keep your Rolex and Bushmills with the cut crystal shot glasses. And of course a new car. :)
So I assume the Republican senators are still at the podium talking, since this is a filibuster?????? Or are they still being allowed to just yell “FILIBUSTER” and receive a get out of jail free card? This is soooo stupid. If it’s a filibuster, then fricking filibuster.
Good on you, newcarguy! I am so very proud of you!!
Always just enough Democrats aren’t there?
And they run it like a pro wrestling tag team.. taking turns being the one or two who monkey wrench whatever good they might possibly do for the rest of us.