If Republicans thought they could bully Harry Reid into backing down about his comments over Mitt Romney’s taxes, they simply miscalculated, and all their outrage has done is keep a story front and center that they would rather push to the margins.
The latest salvo in the intensifying spat comes from Reid’s chief of staff David Krone, who upped the taunts by calling Republicans “a bunch of cowards” and “henchmen for Romney” in an interview with Politico late Sunday night.
“To turn it around, all their childish rants this weekend about calling Reid a ‘liar’ and all that, it just shows you how scared they are that Harry Reid was telling the truth,” Krone told the paper [...]
(Reid’s) spokesman Adam Jentleson responded in the afternoon by vouching for the credibility of the source and inviting Romney to disprove the claim by releasing a series of tax returns. Calling him the “most secretive candidate since Richard Nixon,” Jentleson told TPM: “It’s clear Mitt Romney is hiding something, and the only way for him to clear this up is to be straight with the American people and release his tax returns.”
It’s useless to try and shame Harry Reid off of this. Reid blasted out a FUNDRAISING SOLICITATION to supporters based on the comments last Friday. He’s willing to take maximum heat as long as the Romney campaign still has to answer for the absence of the tax returns further back than 2010.
On the substance, Marcy Wheeler has credible speculation that the “taxes” in question are probably tithes to the Mormon church, which a Mormon Bain investor would say to Mormon Harry Reid, and which would be evident in the lack of charitable donations on the tax returns. But again, it’s all speculation until Romney comes up with the goods.
Considering that Romney’s entire advertising strategy is based on willfully quoting the President out of context, I’m bored by a debate over whether or not Reid is “playing fair.” As for whether this whole tax returns flap matters at all, that’s a more open question. When you attach it to Romney’s actual tax policy, that he wants to lower taxes on the rich and either put the balance toward the deficit or increased taxes on the middle class, it makes a bit more sense as an issue. It all has a sort of bread and circus quality to it, but when the fights happen over words and slights and comments rather than policies that affect millions, this is the politics we get in America.





28 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Joe’s with us on everything except
the warHarry Reid:Lieberman: Reid ‘went over the line’ in questioning Romney’s taxes
http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/242361-lieberman-reid-went-over-the-line-in-questioning-romneys-taxes
Willard still has not filed his taxes for 2011 or released them.
How is it Willard has been unemployed for the last 5 years but still can’t complete his taxes on time.
What does this say for getting things done if Willard is prez.(God/Joe Smith forbid).
Romney could easily back Harry down just by releasing those tax returns. I would bet there is more shit in them.
hmmm… the 1% seems to be circling the wagons. Does this mean that Obama will “win” in November?
Pass the popcorn, and stay tuned for the next Act in this Kabuki Show entitled “General Election 2012.” Not to be confused with General Hospital.
Well, I’m still voting for the LDS angle.
But just in case that isn’t enough, I’m voting for the omerta of the 1%.
Aside from losing face in front of the church, the only thing I figure keeping Willard’s spine stiff in this is the continued strong support of the capitalist aristocracy. They have zero interest in a three month long high profile discussion about how they do business. They would rather pay the protection money than have Mitt spill the beans.
Even without his returns, stuff like this is steadily oozing out:
There’s just too much of an unacceptable risk to the 1% to let the vast unwashed start pawing through the 1000′s and 1000′s of pages of Mitt’s tax returns, and learn how the game is played, and by whom.
So they pay up. And hope it doesn’t end up with Weeping and a-wailing tonight
I really wish you would bring up the birther “controversy” every time you visit this issue. It was OK for the entire Republican party to pile on the president (or shrug their shoulders and say “I’m not sure”) about his birth certificate and not being born in the States but it’s not OK for a single Democrat senator to insist Romney produce his tax returns. Talk about a bunch of babies. Harry Reid isn’t playing fair!!! Boo hoo hoo.
And what this all comes down to, for the 2nd presidential election in a row is the failure of the Republicans to vet their candidates. Plain and simple, they’ve lost the ability to vet a ticket that is palatable to American public at large, even when the odds are completely in their favor, with the economy on its knees, and the first African American president in the white house.
Well, to calm the waters Mitt’s campaign has released his high school report card. That should settle it with the corporate media.
And radio’s Sean Hannity did an irrational rant about how it’s up to Reid to prove what he’s saying….used lots of other examples to keep the focus on Reid. Abbbsurd.
I guess there would be an interesting confluence of religiousness with two oposing LDSers facing off with commentary from the fascist Catholicism that Hannity brings to bear, but I don’t know that it serves the discourse, as limited as it may be. What is the liberal, Protestant take on this religious conflagration, Reverend?
And I bet this is setting a highwater mark for future presidential elections. Ye gods
A lot of people are calling Harry Reid a liar. After all, he’s practically begging to be called a liar. Every time they call him a liar, he’ll remind them what he’s lying about and double down. The GOP fell for the trick they invented, outrage about an opponent’s statement, dominating the news cycle. Meanwhile Harry’s approval rates are shooting up, and Harry is hearing cha-ching with every foam-flecked accusation.
This is Karl Rove and Lee Atwater on steroids. Harry Should buy the GOP a microphone and rent a stadium to make sure everyone gets a chance to hear them whine. Ride this horse until it drops.
*snort* Edit: for onitgoes@4
Really? No one asked him about those tax returns that would make ole Harry look like a fool? Or is the fool Romney
Hey RNC we do care if Romney cheated this country on his taxes.
We care a lot. So put up you tax cheat Romney. Prove to us you didn’t cheat.
Why should we believe you when we know you have your money stashed all around the world?
Make-believe Politics. Yeah, it’s fun to see the Repugs squirm, but where are/were the Democrats when it comes to anything that truly matters?
Brave, brave, Harry Reid!
I knew he had the courage of Lincoln when he refused to kowtow to all those sick, elderly, americans who selfishly wanted access to inexpensive generic drugs, and instead, he stood up for the right of Prizer and Lilly and the rest of the poor little drug companies who were just trying to make an honest buck and he killed the Dorgan Amendment.
Contemplating the political risk he (and Obama) took, brings tears to my eyes.
Some view of the power of Truth…that Truth shall set you free comes to mind.
Well, at least Reid is good for something. Unlike Lieberman who is good for nothing.
Obviously Reid was practicing filthy ,scandalous politics.Good.A lesson for fight-fairly pansies on how the dems can win .They finally realize everyone knows they are corrupt and pimped by corporate-elites,and no longer need to pretend they won’t sink to the pubs level for naif-appeal .Fox always plants evil , filthy gossip with the preface .”some people are saying .Obviously I’m in it for the theatrics and don’t give a shit about either party .
What an utterly predictable shitstain Joe is. Just worthless, worse than worthless really.
Really???? While running a majority in the Senate he has backed down on everything of consequence he ever promised since at least 2008. The Obots and democrats are the far more effective evil compared to the republicans. Pretending Reid is standing on principle is tragically comic.
Hey, we need to make it clear to TPTB why we don’t want either of them.
But I tell you what, I will scream bloody murder over a criminal elite tax cheat thinking he can hide his money offshore and become president of this country.
Respectfully, I think “bread and circuses” is a misread. It SHOULD matter whether a billionaire pays his fair share of taxes, should matter to everyone. Whether the electorate can be moved to CARE is another question. Whether or not they can be made to will likely hinge on just how egregious his failure to pony up has been (we can already assume that he has shirked considerably, right?)
The Wheeler piece is fascinating. But is driving down the vote in Nevada and Colorado really Reid’s motivation? I doubt it’s at the top of the list, just a nice piece of potential collateral fallout. I think it’s simpler, a no-lose proposition for the Dems. Reid’s got it on good authority that Romney paid nothing, but even if it’s not true there’s likely to be plenty of fodder IN those returns. And Reid will have kept the issue alive for SEVERAL WEEKS. In a close campaign, voter reaction may not even register on the Richter scale. But for that sliver of the Independent electorate that all the billions are really being paid out to capture, this issue could help tip the scales.
A lot of voters WON’T care if Romney skirted tax laws to save some money. But if its 100s of millions, and if you can draw a picture of ridiculous wealth and connivance with it–as the DETAILS that come with such returns can do–now you’re making the evening news. That’s the kind of titillation (horses, mansions, secret accounts for the wife, etc., 50 million $ shelters for the kids) that sells soap and delivers votes.
You’re not getting it.
What is at stake here is power.
If Romney is forced to release his taxes it pours fuel on the class war fire.
The people get to see how the low taxes and loop holes given to “job creators” actually work in practice for all the schmucks whom David Brooks wants us to worship.
Dems will burn the house down if they get to rule over the rubble. Walter Karp wrote about this principle. Mitt on the other had has more to lose. He has a lot of personal wealth at risk, not just potential power.
I agree completely that it should matter that an obscenely rich guy who wants to be president hasn’t paid his fair share of taxes,and I think it *does* matter to most voters. Doesn’t everyone want a fairer tax system?
What is objectionable is that Romney’s tax forms matters to the people who create the tax system that allows the obscenely rich guy to skate on taxes only to the degree that it lets their team win the election. It doesn’t matter to Harry Reid that the tax system is egregiously unfair– he has spent his career helping to create it. Reid will, however be happy to exploit romney’s tax problems to consolidate his own power.
Yes–sorry; I think we can take it for granted that the Dems are the second party of a collapsing early 21st century neoliberal capitalism, predicated on militarism and super-exploitation of not just America’s working people, but the planet’s. :) But if the core issue of economic injustice is at the forefront of the Presidential contest we edge closer to a debate about what really matters; if that is what galvanizes voters we are a little closer to pushing the political system to respond to our real needs.
There’s somebody besides Romney who could clear this up but hasn’t said a word yet. John McCain has seen the returns in question but I don’t hear him calling Reid a liar. His silence is deafening.
I think the real situation is there are a lot of higher ups in the know, in just for instance: the McCain campaign, the Mormon leadership, and Bain. I suspect that a lot of people in the Republican leadership and in Washington know also and that probably includes Harry Reid. I suspect that Reid is furious that it looks like Romney is going to get away with it. He also probably gets important people calling him complaining about how the asshole they all know is getting away with it. Reid decided to take one person complaining about it public.
All this is supposition but consistent with the known facts.
To quote a Republican friendly operative, It would be irresponsible not to speculate.