In voter suppression news, a big ruling in Ohio paves the way for thousands of wrong-precinct provisional ballots to be counted.
A federal judge ruled Monday that Ohio must count improperly cast ballots this fall if the mistake is caused by an election worker rather than the voter, a small but potentially significant issue in an important presidential battleground state [...]
“Recent experience proves that our elections are decided, all too often, by improbably slim margins — not just in local races . . . but even for the highest national offices,” U.S. District Judge Algenon L. Marbley wrote. “Any potential threat to the integrity of the franchise, no matter how small, must therefore be treated with the utmost seriousness.”
The legal fight is probably not over. “We respectfully disagree with the judge’s ruling and will likely appeal,” said Matt McClellan, a spokesman for Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted (R).
Basically, the wrong-precinct ballots will get counted if the reason can be attributed to poll worker error. In urban counties in Ohio, often several precincts vote at the same polling place. It becomes very easy for a voter to use the wrong precinct to vote, and then to have to cast a provisional ballot. So once again, the rule favored by the state would have a disproportionate effect on minority voters in the cities. The ruling overturns that, though there will be an appeal to the 6th Circuit Court.
Meanwhile, in Pennsylvania, the Department of State unveiled their new voter ID card, which does not carry driving privileges but is intended for those eligible voters that have no picture ID.
The plan for the “voter-only” cards was announced this summer after it became clear that some voters, particularly elderly people born in other states, were running into an array of difficulties obtaining their birth certificates or Social Security cards.
Unlike the nondriver’s ID, which requires a raised-seal birth certificate and Social Security card, the new ID requires applicants to provide just their name, address, Social Security number, proof of residency, and previous name and/or address if either changed in the preceding 12 months.
The applicant must also be registered to vote.
Voters now have 10 weeks to get the cards. There are 71 DMVs serving Pennsylvania, and 13 of them are open only once a week. And in addition, voters requiring the ID will probably need to make more than one trip to the DMV. So for those without transportation, those who have difficulty speaking English, the disabled, the elderly, etc., there are still hurdles to overcome.
Recent polling in Pennsylvania has led Republicans and outside groups to pull out of the state, so maybe they don’t view the voter suppression tactics as enough to stop a landslide for Obama in November. However, there are other races on the ballot as well, and any close race could see a boost for the Republican from this new rule. Moreover, voter rules even in states not central to the election can make a big difference. South Carolina is protesting a Justice Department ruling on their voter ID law in federal court this week. They want to supersede the Voting Rights Act’s pre-clearance rules and institute their own voting laws, despite their history of discrimination. If they’re successful, it will open the floodgates for a host of voter suppression tactics in the states covered by Section 5 of the VRA.




13 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Ohio should have jailed Sec.of State Ken Blackwell in 2004. Failing to prosecute the mastermind of Ohio’s massively fraudulent 2004 presidential election emboldened other republican criminals to follow in his footsteps, and we now have John Husted.
Ive been without and ID before. Working people will have a hard time. Just the Social Security part took me 3 hours of just sitting around. And I never actually even got a freaking SS card. Luckily they were able to give me a “reciept” of some kind that had my # on it that the DMV found acceptable.
Its a circular maze if you dont have all the paperwork. To get A,
you need B & C, to get B you need A & C, etc….
The most infuriating thing was that I had a drivers license but it had been expired for 2 years so no one would accept it as “valid”
The DMV part took hours IIRC. Which seemed really weird because there were like 100 “working” there.
Now I HAD to go thru my ordeal because I had started a new job to prove I was a US citzen and could work in the US — other BS laws from republicans. If the only reason you need the ID is just to vote I think 9/10 people arent going to go thru the all the hassles.
It also cost a fair amount in fees. IIRC just to get a “raised seal” Birth Certificate was like $60.
I had to get one from out-of-state and it was $40 for me. Not a small amount if you’re living on very little anyway.
Here’s a process for Obtaining a Free PennDOT Secure ID for Voting Purposes:
http://www.dmv.state.pa.us/voter/voteridlaw.shtml
Did you happen to read this report on the process?
Heard the pod cast from Steve Herzenberg
PBPC is a project of the Keystone Research Center
KRC Executive Director Stephen Herzenberg
He didn’t sound real “non-partisan”
I didn’t hear the podcast, but I don’t see protecting the right to vote and facilitating the exercise of that right as partisan,and based on the projct report protecting the right to vote doesn’t appear to be happening in PA.
http://pennbpc.org/voter-ID
•In only 13% of observations was there signage in the reception area indicating a voter ID could be obtained. In almost half the visits, neither signs nor written information was observed.
•While most PennDOT staff encountered by our volunteers were familiar with the request for voter ID, in nearly half the visits individuals were given incomplete or inaccurate information.
•Few PennDOT staff volunteered that a voter ID could be acquired for free, and in three in 10 cases, volunteers were told incorrectly that they would have to pay.
•The standard form for obtaining a non-photo ID does not indicate that it is available for free to certain voters, and a second form required to get the ID was not readily available.
•The number and hours of operation of PennDOT offices are quite limited. There are 71 driver’s license centers in all of Pennsylvania, and nine counties do not have any centers at all. In an additional 20 counties, the driver’s license center is open three days a week or less.
•One in five volunteers had to return a second time because the Driver License center or Photo License center was closed.
So what is going on? You have Todd Akin, Voter ID, Nobody likes Romney and he is still in a vitural tie with President Obama. Obama should be winning going away. Soro’s the liberal conterpart to the Koch’s has barely given pocket change to the Obama relection. What kind of issues and candidates can the left find to light the fire of citizens of the US.
Duh, why would Soros give? Obama sold out all the good causes Soros wanted him elected for and also would not meet with him to hear his opinion, but is always open to banksters’ opinions. Soros is still generous, he just has better things to do with his money — as do I. Soros is a liberal but Obama is NOT — why give money?
Romney is horrible and I prefer Obama to win, but Obama is horrible too and if I’m actually putting in time, money, or effort, it will be for SOMETHING/SOMEONE better than Obama (hmmm, Sherrod Brown, maybe?).
Was reply to alan1tx@6
In other words, Obama has bought and paid for the lack of enthusiasm MANY of his former supporters evince. Kick your base in the teeth, and then be surprised when they aren’t still madly enthusiastic!
Sherrod Brown is a good progressive voice. I’ve sent him money, but it’s really challenging to think about sending Obama money. Sherrod Brown will get out more progressive voters in Ohio than Obama. Supporting Brown, Elizabeth Warren, Tammy Baldwin is the best thing for progressives to do, and maybe the corporate dems will figure out that their base sees thru their corporate supporting bullshit.
The left needs to learn to primary from the left like the right has learned to primary (and win) from the right. Until this happens the left has no chance.