Chicago public school students will not return to the classroom on Monday, as the Chicago Teachers Union decided to take more time to mull over a contract proposal. Students will not return to class until Wednesday at the earliest, according to the union.
The delegates could vote to end the strike as early as Tuesday, as members want the additional time to digest the details of the contract offer, union president Karen Lewis said.
“They’re not happy with the agreement. They’d like it to be a lot better for us than it is,” Lewis said.
The potential for 120 school closings in the coming years, first reported by the Tribune, also has caused concern.
“It under-girds everything they talk about,” Lewis said.
Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel said he plans to file an injunction to force the teachers back to work. He claims that the strike is being waged over non-strikable issues. Legislation in Illinois passed in the last year mandates that teacher strikes can only be conducted over compensation-related issues. Emanuel also said that the strike “endangers the health and safety of our children.” The injunction would go through a circuit court in Chicago, and would have to turn on the court being in the heads of the individual strikers in the CTU as to their rationale for the strike.
The House of Delegates, comprised of roughly 700 CTU members, clearly did not feel confident in making this decision for the over 26,000 teachers in Chicago. They will now discuss the issue with their members and return for a vote on Tuesday. Monday is the Jewish New Year, so that day will be skipped.
Incidentally, the claims we heard all along about a 16% raise over four years were found to be bogus when the union released some details of the contract. The same for the idea that teacher evaluations from high-stakes testing was the main stumbling block.
The proposed deal calls for a three-year contract, with an option for a fourth year that both the district and union would have to agree to. There would be 3 percent raises in years one and four, and 2 percent raises in years two and three, according to the union.
So-called “step and lane” increases, raises given out for years of service and continuing education, would be preserved under the contract, according to the union. And the three highest steps would be increased.
The union also said it had come to an agreement with CPS officials on the sticky issues of performance reviews and teacher recall when schools close. Standards for teacher evaluations that could lead to firings would be eased, and some higher-rated teachers could get a better shot at being recalled after layoffs, sources said.
That’s a 10% raise over four years, tops. And the fourth year, with a slightly higher raise than years 2 and 3, comes with an option. This is a big comedown from the initial 30% raise sought by the union, which they came off from quickly. But it does show that pay didn’t matter as much to the teachers as the changes in work conditions, around not just evaluations (student tests will be capped at 30% of the overall assessment) and the recall procedure for the anticipated 120 school closings over the coming years, but the physical conditions inside the schools. Under the deal, 600 non-core subject teachers in art, music, language and physical education will be hired. Students will actually receive the textbooks for classes on the first day. Non-teaching personnel like school nurses, social workers and support staff will be hired contingent on additional revenue. The teachers wanted better schools, and under this contract they might get them. But they want some details filled in before signing off. Here’s the outline of the tentative agreement, provided by CTU.
Emanuel has been damaged by the strike, and the teachers have forged a strong bond with their communities, articulating the issues with the schools they would like to see ameliorated. The delay in calling off the strike could cause that bond to waver, but that remains to be seen. The delegates don’t trust the school board, and they have ample reason to withhold that trust.
More broadly, the teacher’s strike remains a moment where the labor movement finally fought back against the corporate-led drift in education policy, based around a set of agreed-to standards that simply aren’t as concrete as the Students First/Waiting for Superman crowd makes them out to be. In a superlative piece, Rick Kahlenberg explains why the strike may yet save Democratic policymakers from themselves on education. “It can’t hurt to force a leading Democrat like Emanuel to spend a little more time negotiating with actual teachers and a little less time wooing hedge fund managers, many of whom passionately back the education policies that rank-and-file teachers despise,” Kahlenberg explains.
Applying business school principles to the education of young children, Emanuel and his wealthy supporters favor firing teachers based heavily on student test score results and deregulating education by expanding the number of charter schools. But while much of the press equates standing up to unions with education reform, key reforms that unions opposed have not worked out as planned. Although 88 percent of charters are nonunion, giving principals in those schools the flexibility that reformers prize, the most comprehensive study of charter schools (backed by pro-charter foundations), concluded that charters are about twice as likely to underperform regular public schools as to outperform them. During the strike, nonunion charter schools have bragged that they remained open, but the lack of teacher voice in these schools helps explain why charters nationally have extremely high rates of teacher turnover.
The theory that a nonunion environment, which allows for policies like merit pay, would make all the difference in promoting educational achievement never held much water. After all, teachers unions are weak-to-nonexistent throughout much of the American South, yet the region hardly distinguishes itself educationally. Indeed, the highest performing states, such as Massachusetts and New Jersey—and the highest performing nations, such as Finland—have heavily unionized teaching forces.
The students in Chicago, many of whom have walked picket lines with their teachers in the past week, have a unique opportunity through the strike to see democracy in action and the importance of solidarity and the power of collective action, Kahlenberg explains. They’ll get to see it for a couple more days.




36 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Who’s winning the publicity wars, teachers or Rahm?
Good Job Chicago Teacher Union!!!
The CTU picked the best time to strike!!! Rahm is probably getting cussed out by the White House daily now!
The CTU knows there is blood in the water now, Rahm politcal career is coming to an end.
The more the public learns about the corporate take over of schools, that is all about money and has nothing to do with education the better.
The CTU strike is waking up teachers all over the USA.
How do you teach kids that don’t come to school on a regular basis? you don’t! However, teacher have to hope these kids can pass a test? so that they can keep their jobs? really? who think this is fair
90% of the problems dealing with USA education has nothing to do with teachers.
Rahm Wall Street buddies got 16 trillion dollar bailout when they mess up the USA economy, what did teachers get? Nothing, but the tax bill
Rahm? is becoming Joke!!! Rahm? do you think Teachers can stop the Crime that is ripping your city a part? really? Rahm
Well,you passed a non sensical law. I wonder if anyone has challenged it in court?
The march to privatize continues. Since private business runs the charter schools, they have to show a profit. And they have to be mindful of taxes. So what to do????? Hmm, oh I know, don’t pay the teachers the same money.
I think teachers have a right to know what the city’s intentions are for the schools. Too bad Rahm doesn’t like it.
I think that is a good question. I know this lady who is generally progressive and blames the teachers. Once she got the facts her opinion changed. That’s the problem. How do you get the word out?
The only thing I will disagree with there is the bailout. the number is $29T per Randall Wray. I trust him.
the longer the CTU strike goes, the more USA citizens will learn the truth about Rahm friends agenda, to destroy education.
Rahm is dead politcally, Rahm dumb A$$ neglected inner city schools to the point that inner city parents are piss beyond belief!
The CTU leadership must be getting great advice! Rahm attacks on the inner city are coming back to bite him, big time.
Other Unions are rallying around the CTU, the White House knows this, thus the reason they are letting Rahm drown.
The word is getting out!! thus the reason the CTU is still striking!!!
The more Rahm attacks the CTU, the stronger the CTU resolved gets, because the parents of inner city kids are furious at the system.
Rahm has basically stated the inner city kids don’t matter!
With the shit I’ve heard in this past week, including the charter schools, is it any wonder what parents think of him? Why is he so stupid about this? You’d think a politcally savy guy, who wears the D on his title, would not be so blatantly anti union.
I get real tired of politicians claiming strike is illegal. What is Rahm going to do arrest all the teachers?
Rahm? is showing, how out of touch he really is? this is not DC, this is main street
all the two dimensional chess will not work on main street
when parents see their kids schools falling a part, and schools in subs, with the best of best in term of equipment and facilities. you can throw the chess board out the room.
Rahm is digging his on grave, eventually other chicago politians will have to pick sides, and most may side with the CTU.
Rahm? does not want this to go to court? very bad idea.
Rahm? does not want the world to see, that their are two public school systems in chicago? one for the Rich and one for the Poor, USA citizens don’t like it when the people like Rahm piss on Kids, pissing on Hippies is o-kay, pissing on Kids, not good
“The same for the idea that teacher evaluations from high-stakes testing was the main stumbling block.”
This was in fact a major stumbling block. Illinois law requires High Stakes testing. The stumbling block was what % of teacher evaluation would be determined by these tests. By striking the CTU got the high stakes % down to 30%, the lowest allowed by Illinois law.
Until today, the CTU by a long shot. National media are mostly totally negative. Local media have to be at least a bit mixed because survey research shows deep and wide support for the teachers. I think this might dip a bit in the next few days as people don’t understand the necessity of getting all the details and discussing them thoroughly before agreeing to the new contract. American short attention span ADHD culture will blame the teachers for being slow, and not recognize that this is inevitable in a genuinely democratic union.
This isn’t democracy in action. If it were a democracy, the issues of pay, testing, and accountability would be put up to voters. I wouldn’t know how the results would turn out, but that would be democracy, not two party negotiating behind closed doors.
“Why is he so stupid about this? You’d think a politcally savy guy, who wears the D on his title, would not be so blatantly anti union.”
Its the money of course. Private for-profit school folks contributed mightily to Emmanuel’s campaign and this is just pay back. Business as usual.
Chicago teachers vote to continue strike
This deal is not what the strike was about!
“At a press conference after the three-hour-long delegates’ meeting, [Karen Lewis] feigned sympathy with the delegates’ decision, declaring hypocritically, ‘Why would you make a decision on something that you haven’t had a chance to really look at?’ — precisely what she had attempted to get delegates to do.”
Yes. and the CTU doesn’t call for a worker’s party. And they don’t call for an armed wing. And they don’t call for barricades in the street. And they don’t build the barricades high enough.
CORE/CTU are doing a brilliant job of bringing a union from the brink of collapse back to being one of (if not the most) militant and democratic large union in the country. But since the barricades aren’t built high enough, we should all condemn them?
Even if the offer should be rejected, why don’t you applaud the delegates and respect the leadership for not frog marching the membership into a deal they don’t support?
You are looking a gift horse in the mouth.
Apparently you didn’t read the articles. CTU leadership is absolutely trying to march the rank-and-file into a deal they (the rank-and-file) don’t support.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen sn1789:
Your comment and analysis of the strike and the efforts of the CTU leadership to not only grow a real union but drag Rahm out into the light of day where this diseased political bloodsucker will shrivel up and eventually disapper is right on. However, I believe that the CTU’s efforts to keep Obama and his slimey Secretary of Education out of the heat is a big mistake both in the short run and for the longer struggle. Here in Wisconsin we learned a lot about corporatist Democratic plans to privatize public education while eliminating the last structure that could possibly revitalize a real progressive union movement. Unfortunately, we learned many of these lessons too late and I for one am now convinced that we should have called ObamaRahma out very early in the recall election period to force him to stand however reluctantly with the teachers and state workers especially to legitimize public union rights and cut him off from his goal of privitizing education. We also should have forced him to sqeeze large Democratic donors for money to get a real alternative candidate instead of Rahm’s empty suited shill, Tom Barrett.
Let’s support the CTU as they stand in front of the brown shirted militia of the Chicago mob and not thow ‘em under the bus because they aren’t sufficiently radical or their ideology ain’t pure enough…the CTU is showin’ us what democracy looks like.
Any change in numbers of kids in the class room or if rahm thinks his job is harder than the kids’ or teachers’ because he gets air conditioning in his office with one person and kids and teachers have to coexist with 42 people in one room in 95 degree F heat and humidity? And rahm can leave anytime he wants to get an iced latte or to splash cold water behind his neck while kids and teachers must roast? Thought it was these kinds of things teachers were striking for.
Citizen Eric Patton:
You’re backwards…if the CTU leadership wanted to push this thing down the rank and file’s throats they would have signed off and called for a vote. Jesus H. Christ on a crutch, don’t shoot at your own troops who are standin’ up to the beast ‘cuz you are next, brother.
Rahm never seemed like a democrat to me. Always wondered why Obama had him as COS. So it’s file and use the system as a dem, then treat others as if you are a GOPher. Sweet.
Citizen Norske, you are right on the money and you were just in the fray. I’m glad to see your insights again.
He’s not a dim, but in Chicago that was the only way to get anywhere. Many of the dims would rather be repugs, as you can tell from the policies they support, but it was easier or more expeditious to be a dim. I’m thinking pelosi, reid, o, feinstein, etc.
I am finding some of the advertising on FDL a bit surprising.
Public school kids could get an outstanding education if all levels of government invested in America’s future by really investing in public education rather than building infrastructure in other nations and fighting BS-treasury-busting wars where our troops are killed by the people the war mongers say we are helping.
BearCountry–exactly. And Obama’s senate mentor.
Agree with post #2–the wall street bailout to the 1% could have given the USA a world class education system. Appears like Rahm-rigging on a national AND local level. Really seems like Rahm-rigging all the way around.
Sez who CTU is corrupt? They seem very impressive to me.
Have collected $127 from colleagues at the school where I teach. We’ll be taking it down to UTLA, which will forward it to the Chicago teachers.
The Nation accepts advertising from all comers; perhaps FDL does so as well. I don’t pay attention to ads in any case, so I don’t really care.
Did you not read the articles? To use the language of FDL, Karen Lewis is in the veal pen.
Aw, hell, you wrote “pelosi”. Now I have to go gargle and take an aspirin, to cleanse myself. Urrr.
Commenting again–public education system is so important to America.
All the testing now. Who are the lobbyists for the private corps that write, distribute, grade and report tests and outcomes that the public teachers and schools are forced to teach toward? Who are the lobbyists for the textbooks and information to run parallel with the tests? Who is behind the lobbyists? These tests appear to actually be some sort of indoctrination to Stepford thinking or to a Stepford society. Not the only one to write this.
Creativity, outstandingness and innovation K-12 is going down the drain. More and more, no cream will be allowed to rise to the top in public schools. Much is quashed with uncomfortable physical conditions, portraying public school teachers as villains, teaching to tests (whose tests and why?) and cut backs. No 1%er should be afraid of 99% progeny. The screws continue to be tightened on public education. Is the Catholic church in on this? Tax the church for better public schools.
Always, new “initiatives” for public schools. When does anyone have time to master methods and see how any of the new initiatives work? All seem like bad ideas coming from on high because they have to change things all the time. Has anyone attempted the method of more funding for better outcomes? On the national level–sell some tanks, a billion dollar embassy or an aircraft carrier. Let that trickle down. Yes, take air conditioners out of all of Rahm’s offices and put them in classrooms. Not roasting helps the learning process. Forcing teachers and students to change methods all the time can create more chaos. Is that the objective from on high? And, make sure the kids hear enough–each evening–how bad the public schools and public teachers are. Teach them that they will–or already have–spent 12-13 years in a public wasteland. That is not helpful. Bad message for a future.
Judge refused to grant Rahm a TRO. Next step: the CTU House of Delegates vote.
The attitude people have toward teachers’ pay has always astounded me. Wouldn’t you want the best and brightest teaching your children? And you pay for the best.
Ooh, baby. Can you hear the veins bulging and pounding on Rahm’s temples, right now?
Mr. Patton:
Many so-called “lefties” are either “low information” voters, or in absolute denial regarding this administration’s policies (and that includes the entire spectrum of policies, from education, to health care, to even Social Security “reform.”
I admire your spunk, but you’re probably wasting your breath. :-)
Good luck.
Blue
Listened to a great interview with Richard Wolff and Dr. Harriet Fraad at SouthernDragon’s Diner this morning. Dr. Fraad mentioned that the Obama children and Biden grandchildren attend the exclusive, private Sidwell Friends school, where tuition is about $28,000 per child. And the standardized tests Obama and Rahm are pushing? Sidwell Friends does not administer standardized tests.
The director of the exclusive, private, U of Chicago’s Lab School, where Rahm sends his kids:
“writing on the University of Chicago’s Lab School website two years ago, Magill noted, “Measuring outcomes through standardized testing and referring to those results as the evidence of learning and the bottom line is, in my opinion, misguided and, unfortunately, continues to be advocated under a new name and supported by the current [Obama] administration.”
Hypocrites.