I wish I had known about this before the Chicago Teachers Union suspended their strike and returned to work, but it may shed some light on the timing of the suspension. At the least, it provides a little more context for what teachers unions have to deal with on the ground.
Apparently the above anti-union ad played non-stop on television in Chicago throughout the strike. It’s the product of Education Reform Now, a group that also sometimes goes by Democrats for Education Reform, depending on what pot of money they want to use. Formed in 2005, Education Reform Now has spent millions of dollars over the past few years, whether massaging public opinion or lobbying state legislatures or intervening in school board races.
Education Reform Now spent $10 million in New York state over a two-year period, lobbying Albany for changes to state law on teacher evaluations. They plan to be active in next year’s mayoral election. Former New York City school chancellor Joel Klein, who eventually made his way to work for Rupert Murdoch at News Corp, was the chairman of the Education Reform Now board. The group is closely affiliated with Students First, Michelle Rhee’s lobbying and advocacy group.
Take a look at some of the other members of the New York effort:
Joel Klein isn’t the only connection between Democrats for Education Reform and StudentsFirstNY. The Education Reform Now board includes some heavy-hitting charter school donors from the hedge fund world, including John Sabat of SAC Capital and Sidney Hawkins Gargiulo of Ziff Brothers Investments. Democrats for Education Reform was co-founded by John Petry of Columbus Capital Management, who also serves on the board of both that organization and Education Reform Now. All three board members are deeply involved in the Success Charter Network run by former City Councilmember Eva Moskowitz – who herself will serve on the StudentsFirst board.
In other words, a coterie of hedge fund managers, who have a vested interest in privatizing education through the charter schools they fund. The group got the Senate Majority Leader in New York to insert a provision into the budget allowing for for-profit charters in New York. It eventually got removed, but it’s sure to be back. That’s the whole enchilada.
Education Reform Now doesn’t disclose its donors, but we do know the other source of funding for the group: foundation money.
Private foundations are playing a growing role in financing the nonprofit educational wings of several prominent K-12 advocacy groups, according to reviews of the foundations’ grant records and annual tax filings.
The efforts they underwrite run from the mundane—translating school district materials into Spanish, for instance—to activities deeply intertwined with policy, such as providing information to parents on topics like teacher evaluation and school choice.
Since 2005, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation has donated or pledged some $5.2 million in grants to Stand for Children’s Leadership Center, including a two-year, $3.5 million grant in 2010 focused primarily on its teacher-quality work. The Eli and Edythe Broad Foundation provided $500,000 in startup costs to StudentsFirst and has funded Education Reform Now to the tune of $2 million since 2008.
And beginning in 2010, the Walton Family Foundation has supported all three of those advocacy organizations, including $2.5 million for Stand for Children, $1 million to StudentsFirst, and $2.4 million to Education Reform Now, which is associated with the political action committee Democrats for Education Reform.
The Walton Family Foundation is what you think, that’s the foundation of the founders of Wal-Mart. Eli Broad is slowly buying up all of Los Angeles. The reputation of Bill and Melinda Gates proceed them. The Pershing Square Foundation, run by Pershing Square Capital Management CEO Bill Ackman, has also donated to Education Reform Now/Democrats for Education Reform. This site has much more on their donor network.
This is a BIG money game. So when a teachers union, even one with a formidable war chest, challenges the prevailing ideology on education reform, they go up against hedge funds and billionaires who will attack and smear them. That’s just a sampling of the pressure they face. They also have to contend with a biased media and a general culture tilted against them as well. Despite all that, parents supported the strike in Chicago. But there was going to be a time limit to that.
I just think that needs to be part of the context of understanding this fight.





34 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
fits right in with the Bush family’s for-profit education software biz. It’s all about the benjamins…kids, opportunity for all…not so much.
The DER and Rahm E’s threat that the strike was illegal got them back to work:
So far, President Obama seems to be supporting the South African Platinum mining company’s idea that once a strike is declared illegal [by Rahm E.], it’s OK to shoot the Slaves who refuse to end their illegal strike.
Wicked corporate entanglements using “money,” to misrepresent, misinform and outright lie, under the guise of First Amendment rights, has become common place in America. The critical reasoning skills of a nation have been compromised via advertising with as much credibility as a “Lucky Strike” Cancer stick ad?
Public Education is a “right” in America. Sadly the “brownshirted” citizen, corporately, ideologically and or politically brainwashed can’t think through the camel dung being thrown at them. So how much of the @ $1.9 billions dollars Americans will squander today transporting people goods and services? Should be put to better “uses,” rather than blown out tailpipe. Good topic for a 5th grade School project. We would probably get very many viable answers from the “mouth’s of babes,” untainted by mammon’s myopic self interest. Instead America gets camel dung pile and Ariosto do face plants…….
Duh.
I’ve given up trying to convince starry-eyed lefties that rather than doing analysis & whining, they need to fight the publicity wars.
This is old news, replaying in every circumstance, and no one on the left is doing anything about it.
You know, TEEVEE has really become a terrible thing
I maintain there is no left left.
The “left” watches TEEVEE too….or Facebook
I would assume the teachers union knew about it, but it’s likely they agreed to suspend the strike because Rahm was in court trying to get an injunction against them due to his getting the state to change the terms of their contract on why they could strike. Though you probably reported that already! :) What I’ve heard is that they are not taking the strike action off the table, just suspending it pending the rest of the contract talks.
Good post. By the way, Education Reform Now uses SKDKnickerbocker for over $4 million of its advertising. Anita Dunn, Obama’s former communications director, Anita Dunn, “has developed SKDK’s public relations and strategic communications practice.”
I agree with that.
This blog is a perfect example.
Got rid of mine about 6 months ago.
Thank you for posting this, David.
To me, this underlines the message that the PTB are desperate for the privatization represented by charter school monopolies – to the extent they will do this sort of a swamp job on television. I don’t think anyone is enlightened or educated by anything that is promoted on TV by advertising – in fact, a lot of it seems designed to depress us, so I no longer watch any advertising, political or otherwise.
When you see an ad on TV these days, for anything, you have to realize the baggage that comes along with it. Big money wants to close ordinary public schools and substitute charters – that puts me on the other side of the issue automatically and should be a warning flag to the public.
Here’s an OnT link, covering a bigger portion that just the schools. 4-min audio at the bottom.
Ads ‘work’ by being more obnoxious than the last round. Only way, psychologically, you can get anyone’s attention.
I just have mine to impress the neighbors (/s)….really. I seldom watch the thing. But I do have to have cable for my internet.
I remember when cable came out in the 80′s. the big deal was No Commercials and a couple of good new movies a month that you didn’t have to pay for.
Now, its’ just SOMA
My $125 30 year old TV went on the fritz, so it was an issue of buying a new one. Waste of money.
I think Michelle Rhee is part of this effort, perhaps no surprise? I’ve been getting emails about ed reform from her with a letterhead that says Students First; when I google Students First in tandem with Ed Reform Now I obtain a hit that takes me to a Bronx org that seems to combine the two.
No one is doing anything cuz the Corps have moved in,present a few people
to the public who utter lefty key phrases & walla they are seen as lefty icons eventhough they are doing the bidding of Corporations.
Particularly in the media,where about 4 Corporations present news to Americans over the public airwaves…..You are never going to get the skinny from people working for Corporations pretending to be lefties.
“…brainwashed by men in little black boxes.”
S.K.
Yup….
She most certainly is….She is pushing “charter” on behalf of the billionaires.
I understand all that.
I don’t have the A as to how to counter it. I’m reading a bio of William Lloyd Garrison partly in the hopes that his abolition quest might provide some clues.
“You are never going to get the skinny from people working for Corporations pretending to be lefties.”
You are never going to get the skinny from people working for Corporations pretending to be lefties or righties, when they are employed by corporations, period!
“Corrected!”
I am at a lost also on what to do….
Yes thank you…
- who said that there was no bipartisanship in the world of modern american politics .. broad agreement on a broad range of issues ..
torture
presidential targeted killings
permanent detention with no charges or trial
imperial wars for the military/industrial/petro complex
warrantless surveillance of all communication
militarized police force crackdowns on dissent
union busting
privatizing public education
dismantling social security & medicare
new NAFTAs sending jobs overseas
new Normal of 15 percent unemployment
new Normal new jobs at lower-than-living wages
insolvent banks propped up with tax dollars
financial criminals get to walk free
debtor prisons
continued foreclosures
fracking is cool
clean coal is real
off-shore drilling is A-OK
transnational gas pipelines are going to happen…
an honest ticket reflecting the modern american ‘concensus party’ would have to really be .. can the old men & call it “Obama/Ryan – Autocracy & Austerity for New America 2012″
or how about a new party ? NoDifferenceAtAll .. or, the NDAA party
The reemergence of an old “cast system,” with leveraged servitude to banks to obtain higher education certifications called “degrees.” Sounds like China during the War Lord’s era or India? The protection of opportunity first starts with education and proper food intake. America today is fat and dumb. Waste .80 cent of every dollar on gasoline transporting services, people and food. Then waste 40% of the food. Never mind trucking costs and diesel fuel price??????????????????????????????????????????????!
Jefferson might call this an extermination event? Corporations and “monied interests” lie all the time, for profit at life’s expense. Fuck the Hedge fund fascists….
Nothing epitomizes the definition of insanity better than lefty blogs.
I drop a comment from time to time to try to get more creative thinking. Strategy, not tactics.,
Debtor’s prisons. Capital idea Acme. Now to set your teeth on edge (make your hair stand on end): I’ve had a couple conversations with young people lately who seem to be unclear about the concept. They are not sure they don’t already exist. “You can’t just not pay your credit card bills; they’ll put you in jail!” How’s that for scary? Brainwashed?
DO you believe the fears of corporate power and money controlling government as expressed by Jeff and Mad is a right left issue? Conservative vs liberal issue?
More time spent on “”Royal Boobies”" than issues (monopolies)bought and leveraged by corporate money which attack the lives, decreasing liberty for many American?
Energy costs rise food goes up. Food goes up energy costs rise? At least a drug addict can say no and sober up, if he chooses. Here what choice do people have? Freeze and starve to death while enjoying alleged liberty, life then freedom, in death?
Work will not set you free, when your servitude is leveraged and by design with limited or no choices, to better the human condition.
Become? TV was born a terrible thing. Like the Claymore antipersonnel mine, it didn’t get this bad without some developmental conceptualization. Applying the lessons learned selling shampoo to the business of selling repressive policies, for intsance. But the capability was part of the package at the outset.
What’s got bad is that Americans seem to have become more susceptible as they have become more addicted to the tube. Common sense would suggest that the targets would become harder to hit, not easier. But that doesn’t seem to be the case. Depressing.
How many times have you typed that on the internet?
Has it changed anything for the better?
Doesn’t matter whether it’s a left-right issue or not. I don’t hang out in righties blogs. Not a team player; go for individual sports.
>>
http://staugustine.com/interact/blog-post/rusty-collins/2012-08-28/body-attachment-debt-can-land-you-jail
&
http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/payday_lenders_using_courts_to_create_modern-day_debtors_prisons/
But …
by gosh and golly – they’re only for poor as shit Americans ..
question : why no jail time for the criminals at AIG who didn’t pay their bills? – - oh, that’s right – the fascist mono-party laps dogs to the banking criminals gave them tax dollars to pay off their welched debts
whooo hooo! equal justice!
vote the NDAA2012 party – no difference at all/national defense authorization act 2012 .. your vote has been ‘permanently detained’
“How many times have you typed that on the internet?”
Many times. Will continue to do so. Repetition is the only way to get points across. Like corporate’s repetitive advertising lies which people accept as truth, while paying the cable bill a month in advance for ads to come in the future?
Better yet, Too bad I can’t brand it into people’s foreheads backwards so when they look in the mirror they can read it every morning. Then maybe we might get somewhere.
“Why no jail time for the criminals at AIG…?”
From San Augustine: “Seek competent legal counsel…”
How does that relate to shit poor American? Badly. Very badly.
Wonder what Frank and Jesse would have said?
My Mom was from Missouri. She did not believe that the James boys were criminals, “They only robbed the railroads; that’s no crime.”