Within a matter of hours, both houses of the Michigan legislature passed right to work legislation, while arrests and lockdowns occurred inside and outside the chamber. In the end, Michigan Democrats staged a walkout to protest the closed Capitol. But eventually, the votes were taken, through a gut-and-amend process with a substitute bill that was supposed to create a commission to deal with labor disputes. The main bill then passed the House by a 58-52 vote, and the Senate 22-16.
You can see by these numbers why the Michigan GOP wanted to get this done fast, within the lame duck session, before the new legislature gets sworn in January 1. Six Republicans crossed the aisle in the state House to vote against the bill. With Democrats picking up five House seats in the election, the new configuration would not have had the votes to pass right to work.
However, if Governor Rick Snyder signs the bill – and he’s made every indication that he would – it will be very hard to dislodge. The legislature added an appropriation of state funds to the right to work bill, which eliminates the possibility of it getting overturned by referendum. But assuming it stands, Republicans still control the legislature and the Governor’s mansion in the next session, and so right to work would be in place for a couple years before unions have a chance to overturn it by retaking state government. And the longer that takes, the more battered unions will become, as the entire point of right to work is to decimate the ability for unions to function. That’s how it has played out in the other 23 states where mandatory dues have been barred for workers operating under collective bargaining agreements.
President Obama did weigh in today, opposing right to work legislation in general and specifically in Michigan. “President Obama has long opposed so-called ‘right to work’ laws and he continues to oppose them now,” said spokesman Matt Lehrich. “The President believes our economy is stronger when workers get good wages and good benefits, and he opposes attempts to roll back their rights. Michigan – and its workers’ role in the revival of the US automobile industry — is a prime example of how unions have helped build a strong middle class and a strong American economy.”
But this hardly matters, as the sneak attack on Michigan workers is almost certain to be successful. Democrats in the House put up a host of amendments that all failed, but were able to force a reconsideration of the bill. However, that’s likely to get dispensed with as a procedural matter, and the suite of bills will pass on a subsequent vote. There are separate bills for private employees and public employees that need to be reconciled and wrapped up. The hammer will probably come down in five days:
The mishmash of bills is creating head-crashing possibilities over when any of it will make it to the governor’s desk.
The quickest the Legislature can now pass the right-to-work bills through both chambers and send them on to Gov. Rick Snyder is five days from the next sitting, or session day, said Ari Adler, a spokesman for House Speaker Jase Bolger, R-Marshall. The next session day could be set for Friday, a day this weekend or Tuesday, Adler said. The five-day clock then starts after that.
Political and labor leaders have implored Snyder not to sign the bill, but he orchestrated this whole thing today, so that doesn’t seem likely to work.
A sad day in Michigan.




16 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
But, but, …
Michigan’s G.O.P. Governor Defies Easy Labels (NYT, August 18, 2012)
The workers elected him. You eat what you bought.
Michigan’s union leadership helped bring this on themselves. They’re the worst advocates in recent political history. (James Rhodes’s comment about George Romney, “He couldn’t sell pussy on a troopship,” comes to mind.) They’ve made no effort to form coalitions with other progressive groups. The unions are dominated by aging, out-of-touch patriarchs, and they’ve presided over the decline of the state Democratic Party to the point of irrelevance.
I used to be a Democratic precinct delegate. This year I walked away from the party, and can’t imagine circumstances under which I come back. The MDP is beyond redemption.
Sound like unions need to develop new strategies. Maybe they can start suing companies for money and concessions. People inside companies know a lot of dirty secrets.
If only Obama had his comfortable walking shoes on…..
Barack Underachiever Obama deserves a healthy share of the blame for what happened in Michigan. He sacked Howard Dean, dismantled the 50-state strategy, squandered his political capital on a health-care bill that was incomprehensible except for the hated individual mandate, and failed to call out the Tea Party as a fringe group riddled with racists and oddball conspiracy theorists. The result of his gross malpractice: a debacle at the federal office level, an absolute rout farther down the ticket.
Republicans hate the very notion of people getting paid for their work. They hate that people can join together in a professional association to use their collective force to require a decent wage and to be able to retire someday. If businesses can form associations to collude against their workers and customers, why shouldn’t their workers be able to join forces in return?
Republicans HATE people that actually WORK for a living, being the party of executives, board of directors, shareholders and fund managers that steal the results of everyone else’s work.
That was 2008 Campaign Obama. I liked him too. Governing Obama, not so much.
And 2012 Campaign Obama wanted a new cabinet position for business because the Secretary of Commerce and the transfer of wealth in the last 20 or 30 years just are not enough.
Tone fucking deaf (on purpose).
It is not business that needs another seat at the table. It’s workers.
I disagree that Obama is an underachiever. I think he has gotten pretty much everything he’s wanted.
Not only Republicans. If our problems were Republicans, we’d be golden.
Our problem is that Republicans are no longer fighting an opposition party.
I don’t find “right-to-work” laws so terrifying. We Wobblies have never believed in dues check-off or mandated dues of any kind. The union must earn the loyalty and money of its members, and many modern business unions aren’t doing that. An absurd percentage of members’ dues is passed on to the worthless Democratic Party rather than being used to organize more workers or improve advocacy for those already members.
Snyder and his fellow Republicans think they put a stake through the heart of the revived workers’ movement. Instead, they may have contributed to it.
Not much difference between the labor bosses and company bosses. They need each other to justify their salaries.
“If businesses can form associations to collude against
theirworkers and customers, why shouldn’ttheirworkers be able to join forces in return?”Hence, the Heritage Foundation? A Tax Exempt corporation like the Tobacco Institute, being mouthpiece under the guise of SCIENCE OR EDUCATION, to put forth lies and BS, to protect rancid business models and profit and for the very same reason Taney’s SCOTUS declared Mr. Scott inferior due to (IGNORANCE) skin color, therefore property, for the economic benefit of entrenched interest of the day. Slave-owner’s, who did not want to compensate a humans for his/her toils. It cost to much? It is all about fucking people’s rights, so a select few can make all the money they want, while paying homage to Mammon’s limp dick, in return for money power greed and avarice?
The same dynamic happened in Wisconsin. The Madison rallies started out as grass roots movements. Then the union leaders and the Democratic Party arrived with their organizational skills, and promptly killed the momentum. They took focus away from bad policy and turned it toward the politics of a recall election.
Good point, Knut @ 2.
In 2010, I came across one remark from a Democratic voter who was getting ready to participate in the Republican primaries. (Michigan is an open primaries state.) The person said that Rick Snyder was appealing to her more so than Pete Hoekstra (the 2012 Senate nominee), and a few other Republican figures who, like Snyder, were seeking the 2010 GOP gubernatorial nod. (Mich. is one of those states in the habit of electing governors from the party opposite a sitting president. That tells you how smart these Democratic voters are, despite their presidential votes making Mich. blue since 1992.)
I thought to myself, “What a fool!” Snyder’s demeanor seeming so harmless and rather affable does not mean he isn’t damaging. But, hey, it’s an example of people not getting themselves involved with politics. You don’t have to go to City Council meetings and do a lot of leg work. Just get yourself reading more and more on what’s happening is pretty damn good.
This seems to be immediate payback for the ballot measure, defeated in November, that would have enshrined unions in the state constitution.
I wonder, will this legislation require that a union represent a worker that chooses not to pay union dues? That was my understanding of what ‘open shop’ means, because a union cannot represent someone that isn’t paying dues, thus a sort of death knell for unions in such an environment. But that is not what I’m hearing, so I dunno.