Written by Amanda Marcotte for RHRealityCheck.org – News, commentary and community for reproductive health and justice.
Randall Terry isn’t just your everyday anti-choice nut. It takes someone with a special level of nuttiness to get shunned by most of the anti-choice community, a community generally known for having a high tolerance for hysterics, attention-seeking, blatant lying, and quiet encouragement of violence against abortion providers. If you’re such a nasty piece of work that even Jill Stanek and Troy Newman can’t stand you, you must be something else.
So why on earth did soon-to-be Speaker of the House John Boehner actually conduct a meeting with Randall Terry and his cadre of extremists? It’s understandable, if disappointing, that such a prominent politician would meet with anti-choice activists. We still don’t live in an era where women’s human rights are above debate, and so it’s to be expected that some politicians will hold meetings based around the concept that women should be forced to bear children against their will. But there are many dozens of anti-choice leaders Boehner could have held meetings with to establish his misogynist bona fides, and cozy up to the Christian right. Why choose the worst of the worst, a man whose primary reputation on the right now is that of a self-aggrandizing blowhard who just screws everything up?
A few possibilities come to mind. First, Boehner might just be ignorant of the battles within the anti-choice movement, and selected Terry for this anti-choice photo op because Terry is just so visible in D.C. After all, Terry is forever making a spectacle of himself. He’s hard to ignore. To someone who only paid minimal attention to the anti-choice movement, it might seem like Terry is more of a leader than he really is. But while incompetence can never completely be taken off the table as a reason that a politician makes a baffling mistake, it’s hard for me to imagine that Boehner and his people could be so ignorant of Terry’s place in the anti-choice world. And if they were ignorant before, the fact that Terry did wacky stuff like put fetus dolls on the table during the discussion should have clued Boehner into the facts.
It’s also possible that Boehner is trying to signal that he’s hardcore when it comes to disrespecting women’s rights. If you want to send that signal, you’re in good shape picking the worst of the worst of the anti-choice community. But again, there are many people that are just as mean-spirited as Terry without being so hated within the larger anti-choice community. Troy Newman, for instance, has just as much distaste for women’s rights and health as Terry, but he has a better reputation in the anti-choice world. So that doesn’t really make sense.
There is another possibility, and that is … Read more